Bill shields workers from reprisals

Summary#

Bill 192, the Speaking Out About Workplace Violence and Workplace Harassment Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Occupational Health and Safety Act. Its stated goal is to protect workers from reprisals when they speak out about workplace violence or harassment. The bill’s text says it would take effect on Royal Assent; the supplied material does not establish whether that occurred.

  • It would prohibit a person from retaliating against a worker for specified actions taken in good faith, including reporting workplace violence or harassment, taking part in an investigation, or speaking publicly about these issues.
  • The protection would also cover workers who comply with the Act, seek advice or enforcement, assist or serve on health and safety committees, refuse work they reasonably believe breaks the Act, give information, or testify in a related proceeding.
  • A reprisal would mean any measure that adversely affects the worker’s employment. Listed examples include ending or threatening employment, demotion, discipline, suspension, penalties such as reduced wages or changed hours, and intimidation or coercion.

What it means for you#

  • Workers: If you take one of the listed actions in good faith, a person could not take an adverse employment measure against you because of it. The bill protects public disclosures as well as reports to an employer, supervisor, health and safety representatives, a union, or an inspector.
  • Workers: The bill would not make every negative workplace decision a reprisal; the measure must be because you took a protected action.
  • Employers and others: They would have to avoid reprisals against workers for the listed actions. The bill does not itself set out a new process for receiving reports or investigating workplace violence or harassment.
  • General public: The bill concerns protection from workplace reprisals. It does not itself create a new general reporting service or change workplace violence and harassment rules beyond the reprisal protection described.

Money#

No publicly available information on costs.

  • The supplied material gives no estimate for staffing, enforcement, or other public costs, and no information about business compliance costs.

What is unclear#

  • The Occupational Health and Safety Act itself was not supplied, so the bill’s exact changes compared with the current wording and any existing procedures could not be verified.
  • The bill text does not define “good faith” or explain how it would be assessed.
  • The bill text does not define workplace violence or workplace harassment; the supplied material does not show whether the Act defines them.
  • It does not set out how a worker would bring a reprisal complaint, how a decision would be made, or what timelines or review rights would apply.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that workers may be more able to report violence or harassment if the law clearly bars retaliation for doing so.
  • Naming protected actions—including taking part in an investigation and speaking publicly—could make the protection clearer for workers and those responsible for employment decisions.
  • Defining reprisals with examples could help show that retaliation is not limited to firing someone.

Case against#

  • The bill covers a wide range of actions, including public disclosures, but the supplied text does not explain how disputed claims would be assessed.
  • “Good faith” is a condition, but the bill text does not explain what it means or how it would be applied.
  • The bill states the prohibition but does not set out a complaint or decision process. That leaves important practical details unclear.