Summary#
Bill 51, the Disclosure of Information Relating to the Protection of Children Act, 2016, would amend Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 and Public Service of Ontario Act, 2006. Its stated goal is to protect people from reprisals for taking steps to report child-protection concerns or disclose information to the Provincial Advocate for Children and Youth.
- Employers and people acting for employers could not intimidate, dismiss, penalize or threaten an employee for specified steps related to the employee’s duty to report suspected child-protection concerns.
- People who work for a “child and family service provider” would count as public servants for Part VI of the Public Service of Ontario Act. That Part sets out a process for public servants to disclose wrongdoing.
- The bill would extend Part VI reprisal protections to specified disclosures connected with the Provincial Advocate for Children and Youth.
- The bill creates no new agency or funding program. It would take effect on Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Employees: If you seek advice about reporting, make a report, cooperate in a process about a report, comply with the reporting duty, or seek to enforce it, your employer could not take or threaten the listed forms of reprisal because of that action. The bill does not change the reporting duty itself.
- People working for child and family service providers: Employees, directors, officers, members, partners and sole proprietors would be public servants for Part VI. The bill does not set out how that Part’s disclosure process would work for them.
- Public servants: The bill adds protection against reprisals for seeking advice about, or making, a disclosure that resulted or may have resulted in the Provincial Advocate carrying out its functions or using its powers, and for making a disclosure under the Advocate’s Act.
- General public: The bill does not create a new front-line service, a new right to receive services, or a process for reviewing every child-protection report.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.
- The bill contains no appropriation, fee or fine, and does not specify spending or staffing.
- Any cost of applying the disclosure and reprisal rules to additional people is not stated.
What is unclear#
- The Employment Standards Act, Public Service of Ontario Act and the referenced Child and Family Services Act were not supplied. I could not verify the existing protections, the full Part VI disclosure process, or the exact meanings of the referenced provider categories against current law.
- The bill does not set out intake rules, decision steps, timelines, appeals or reporting requirements for disclosures.
- The supplied material does not establish whether the bill passed after introduction. No publicly available information on its later status is included.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to reduce the risk that workers will face workplace punishment for taking steps related to reporting suspected harm to a child.
- Extending Part VI status and reprisal protection to child and family service providers could give their workers a route to disclose wrongdoing without losing the protections available under that Part.
- Including advice-seeking and cooperation, not just completed reports or disclosures, could protect people earlier in the process.
Case against#
- The bill extends Part VI to several categories of people working for child and family service providers, but does not explain how its existing disclosure process would apply to them.
- The bill does not specify implementation costs, staffing or guidance for employers and service providers.
- Because the parent Acts are not included, the scope of existing protections and the rules that would apply alongside these amendments cannot be confirmed from the supplied material.