Summary#
Bill 118, the Occupiers’ Liability Amendment Act, 2020, amends Ontario’s Occupiers’ Liability Act. It was enacted as Chapter 33 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2020. It adds a 60-day written-notice rule for personal-injury claims caused by snow or ice against an occupier or a contractor hired to remove snow or ice. The stated effect is to require early notice, subject to exceptions.
- An injured person must give notice within 60 days of the injury, including its date, time and location, by personal service or registered mail.
- Notice to one occupier or snow-and-ice removal contractor is effective for a claim against any of the people covered by the rule, including those who did not receive the original notice.
- An occupier who receives notice must send a copy to the other relevant occupiers and snow-and-ice removal contractors. A contractor who receives notice must send a copy to the occupier who hired it.
- Missing or insufficient notice does not bar a claim if the injured person dies from the injury, or if a judge finds a reasonable excuse and that the defendant is not prejudiced in its defence.
What it means for you#
- People injured by snow or ice: If you bring a personal-injury claim against an occupier or a contractor hired to remove snow or ice, you generally must give the required notice within 60 days. If you miss the deadline or the notice is insufficient, a judge may allow the action if there was a reasonable excuse and the defendant was not harmed in its ability to defend the case.
- Occupiers and snow-and-ice removal contractors: If you receive notice, you must send a copy to the other relevant party or parties named in the Act. The bill does not set a deadline for sending those copies.
- People bringing a claim: The rule concerns claims for personal injury caused by snow or ice. It does not, by itself, ban those claims.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s public cost or any cost estimate.
- The bill requires certain occupiers and contractors to send copies of notices, but the available material gives no estimate of the related costs.
What is unclear#
- The bill says it comes into force on a day set by proclamation, but the supplied material does not give that date.
- The supplied material does not include the full Occupiers’ Liability Act, so I could not verify how this change compares with all of the Act’s current rules.
- The bill does not define “snow or ice” or explain how the rule applies to particular situations.
- It does not set out a process for giving notice beyond the required information and methods of service.
Case for#
- Early notice may help occupiers and contractors identify the location and circumstances of an injury while details are still available.
- Allowing notice to one covered person to apply to all covered defendants avoids requiring separate initial notices to each one.
- The death and judge-made exceptions mean the notice rule is not an absolute bar in those circumstances.
Case against#
- A 60-day deadline may be difficult for an injured person to meet, and missing it can bar a claim unless an exception applies.
- Whether a late or insufficient notice is excused depends on a judge finding both a reasonable excuse and no prejudice to the defendant’s defence.
- The bill does not set a deadline for occupiers or contractors to pass notice on to the other relevant parties.