Hiring notices and safety rules bill

Summary#

The Working for Workers Five Act, 2024 is an enacted Ontario law that amends six existing Acts; it does not create a single new program. Its stated goal is to improve workplace standards and fairness in hiring, and to reduce barriers to skilled trades. Some changes start at different times, including when proclaimed, and the supplied material does not say which proclamation-based changes have started.

  • Hiring: Once in force, employers must say in publicly advertised job postings whether a job is an existing vacancy, provide other information set by regulation, and give interviewed applicants prescribed information within a prescribed time. Exceptions may also be set by regulation.
  • Sick leave and fines: Employers may ask for reasonable evidence of entitlement to sick leave, but cannot require a certificate from a qualified health practitioner. The maximum fine for an individual convicted under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 rises from $50,000 to $100,000.
  • Trades and regulated professions: Regulations may set alternative academic criteria for skilled-trades training. Regulated professions must have policies for accepting reasonable alternatives to qualification documents that applicants cannot obtain for reasons beyond their control, and plans for allowing parts of registration to proceed at the same time.
  • Workplace safety: The law expands harassment definitions to cover certain virtual activity, applies the safety law to telework in or around a private home subject to prescribed exceptions and conditions, and allows some required information to be posted electronically if workers can readily access it.
  • Washrooms and reviews: When washrooms are provided for workers, constructors on projects and employers must keep them clean and sanitary and keep cleaning records as prescribed. An official appointed to conduct an internal review under the Ontario Immigration Act, 2015 may delegate their powers or duties.
  • Compensation claims: The law extends a work-related post-traumatic stress disorder presumption to specified wildland firefighters and investigators, subject to eligibility and timing rules. It also creates a presumption for primary-site skin cancer for prescribed firefighters and fire investigators with at least 10 years of qualifying service before diagnosis.

What it means for you#

  • Job applicants: If you are interviewed for a publicly advertised job, the employer must provide prescribed information within the prescribed time. The bill does not require employers to interview applicants or to advertise every vacancy.
  • Employees: Your employer cannot require a medical certificate from a qualified health practitioner to support sick leave, but may ask for other evidence that is reasonable in the circumstances. If workplace information is posted electronically, the employer must tell workers where and how to access it.
  • Workers who telework: The Occupational Health and Safety Act applies to telework in or around a private residence, subject to exceptions and conditions that may be prescribed. The exact scope of those exceptions is not in the supplied material.
  • Skilled-trades trainees and applicants to regulated professions: Alternative academic criteria may be set for trades training. Professions must set out acceptable alternatives to unavailable qualification documents and plan for registration steps to happen concurrently where possible. The Fairness Commissioner reviews these policies and plans; regulations may require approval or changes.
  • Wildland firefighters and investigators: Eligible workers may benefit from the PTSD presumption when making claims. Some past diagnoses and pending claims have special transition rules and deadlines. The law does not make every claim automatically eligible.
  • Firefighters and fire investigators: The skin-cancer presumption applies only to prescribed workers who meet the 10-year service requirement. The supplied material does not identify which workers are prescribed.
  • Employers and constructors: If they provide worker washrooms, they must keep them clean and sanitary and keep records as regulations require. The law does not itself require them to provide washrooms.
  • People dealing with immigration internal reviews: The appointed reviewer may delegate powers or duties; the law does not require delegation.
  • Current-law comparison: The supplied material describes the amendments but does not include the parent Acts. I could not verify the full current-law baseline or how these changes interact with all existing rules.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • Employers, constructors and regulated professions will have new record-keeping or policy and planning duties; any resulting costs are not estimated.
  • The Fairness Commissioner will review professions’ policies and plans, but the material gives no staffing or funding estimate.
  • The maximum fine for an individual convicted under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 increases to $100,000; the material does not estimate fine revenue.

What is unclear#

  • The regulations will set key details for job postings, interview information, exceptions, records, and some skilled-trades criteria. Those details are not supplied.
  • The bill does not define “publicly advertised job posting” or specify what information interviewed applicants must receive.
  • The rules for accepting alternative qualification documents and allowing registration steps to proceed together may depend on regulations. The full approval process and timelines are not supplied.
  • The bill allows prescribed exceptions and conditions for safety rules applying to home telework; their scope is unknown here.
  • The washroom cleaning-record requirements and any additional rules are left to regulations.
  • The supplied material does not give proclamation dates for changes that require proclamation, or identify which of those changes are in force.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make hiring more transparent by requiring vacancy status in job ads and information for interviewed applicants.
  • Allowing reasonable alternatives to missing qualification documents could help applicants whose records are unavailable for reasons beyond their control.
  • Plans for concurrent registration steps could let applicants continue other steps while one part is delayed.
  • Extending PTSD and skin-cancer presumptions recognizes specified work-related risks and may make it easier for eligible workers to establish that conditions are work-related.

Case against#

  • Many practical rules depend on regulations not included here, so employers, applicants and professions may not yet know exactly what will be required.
  • The bill sets duties for employers, constructors and professions without estimating their compliance costs or the resources needed for reviews.
  • The Fairness Commissioner may be given approval or change powers by regulation, but the bill text does not establish when those powers will apply.
  • Presumptions do not guarantee benefits: eligibility, service, diagnosis and timing conditions still apply, and the supplied material leaves some prescribed-worker details unknown.