Summary#
Bill 42, the Highway Traffic Amendment Act (Waste Collection Vehicles and Snow Plows), 2016, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. Its stated goal is to extend safe-driving rules around certain stopped vehicles to waste collection vehicles and snow plows, including when they are moving.
- Drivers approaching a waste collection vehicle that is collecting garbage or material for disposal or recycling from the roadside must slow down and proceed with caution.
- Drivers must follow the same rule when approaching a snow plow with flashing blue lights. Both rules apply whether the vehicle is stopped or travelling.
- On a road with at least two lanes in the same direction, a driver in the same lane or an adjacent lane must move to another lane if it is safe.
- The bill keeps the option to stop instead of passing, if stopping is safe and not otherwise prohibited by law.
What it means for you#
- Drivers: If the bill became law, you would have to slow down and proceed cautiously around the specified waste collection vehicles and snow plows. On roads with multiple lanes in your direction, you would also have to move over when required, if it is safe.
- Waste collection and snow-plow operators: The bill does not add a duty for operators to apply for approval or follow a new operating process. It defines which vehicles are covered: waste collection vehicles operated by or for a municipality, specified local bodies, or the Ontario Crown; and road service vehicles used for snow or ice control that have flashing blue lights.
- Other road users: The bill does not change the rules for approaching vehicles outside the listed categories. The supplied text does not state a fine or other penalty for breaching the new duties.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill does not state a public spending amount, fee, fine, or business cost.
- No publicly available information is provided about costs of complying with the new driving rules.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the Highway Traffic Act as it currently stands, so the existing law and the full effect of replacing its provisions could not be verified.
- The bill does not define terms such as “in the course of collecting” or explain what counts as moving over “if the movement can be made in safety.”
- The bill does not set out how the new rules would be enforced or state what penalty would apply.
- The text says the Act would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not establish whether the bill passed or received Royal Assent.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that roadside collection and snow-clearing can put workers outside vehicles near passing traffic. Requiring drivers to slow down and proceed cautiously addresses that risk directly.
- The move-over rule gives drivers a specific action to take on multi-lane roads, where changing lanes is safe.
- Applying the rules to vehicles that are stopped or moving could cover roadside work that a rule limited to stopped vehicles would not.
Case against#
- The bill does not explain how drivers should judge when changing lanes is safe, or how the rule applies when traffic or road conditions make moving over difficult.
- Coverage depends on details such as the vehicle’s operator, its work at the time, and— for snow plows—its flashing blue light. The bill does not explain how drivers are expected to identify those details in every situation.
- The supplied text gives no penalty, enforcement details, or cost estimate, so the practical consequences of the new duties are not clear.