Injured workers' earnings rule reform

Summary#

Bill 119, the Respecting Injured Workers Act (Workplace Safety and Insurance Amendment), 2019, would amend Ontario’s Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, 1997. Its stated goal is to stop the Workplace Safety and Insurance Board (WSIB) from counting income from work a worker does not actually have when calculating loss-of-earnings payments.

  • The WSIB would be barred from counting earnings from a job the worker does not hold, unless the job was offered and the worker failed to accept it “without good cause.”
  • The WSIB would be barred from counting earnings from a business the worker does not carry on.
  • The change would apply to calculating earnings the worker is able to earn in suitable and available employment or business. The supplied explanatory note says the current law allows the WSIB to count earnings from suitable and available work a worker does not have.
  • The Act would start on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Injured workers receiving loss-of-earnings payments: If the WSIB is calculating your payment, the bill would limit when it can count earnings from a job you do not hold or a business you do not operate. This would not automatically set your payment amount or change every injured worker’s payment.
  • Workers offered a job: The WSIB could still count earnings from that job if you did not accept it “without good cause.”
  • WSIB: The Board would have to follow these limits when deciding what earnings a worker is able to earn.
  • The bill does not directly change workplace safety rules or create a new benefit program.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the supplied material. No publicly available information.

  • The bill could affect the amount of loss-of-earnings payments in cases where the WSIB would otherwise count income from a job or business the worker does not have.
  • The bill gives no estimate of the number of affected claims or the total payment impact.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “good cause,” or set out how the WSIB should decide whether a worker had it.
  • The explanatory note describes the exception as a worker refusing work in “bad faith,” while the bill’s operative wording says “without good cause.” The bill does not explain how those standards relate.
  • The bill does not set out a new decision process, timeline, appeal route, or reporting requirement.
  • The parent Act was not supplied, so the current wording and operation of section 43 could not be checked beyond the explanatory note.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make loss-of-earnings calculations reflect work a worker actually has, rather than income from suitable work that is unavailable to them.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that a worker should not have payments reduced based on earnings from a business they do not operate.
  • The exception for a job offered and refused without good cause leaves room to count those earnings in that circumstance.

Case against#

  • One concern is that limiting the WSIB’s ability to count earnings from work a worker does not hold may change how it assesses the worker’s ability to earn.
  • The bill bars counting earnings from a business the worker does not carry on, without stating an exception.
  • The bill does not define “good cause” or provide details for applying that test, which may leave important decisions to WSIB practice.
  • The payment and administrative effects are unknown because the bill provides no cost or impact estimate.