Temporary earnings cap reshapes employer premiums

Summary#

Bill 238, the Workplace Safety and Insurance Amendment Act, 2021, became law as Chapter 3 of Ontario’s 2021 statutes. It amended the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, 1997 by setting a temporary limit on the earnings used to calculate certain employer premiums and giving the Minister a power to require information from the Workplace Safety and Insurance Board (WSIB). The stated goal of the information power is to support the proper administration of the Act.

  • For the period starting January 1, 2021, the premium payable by an employer for each worker applied only up to $97,308 in average earnings, unless a different amount was prescribed.
  • Regulations could extend that special rule beyond December 31, 2021, but not beyond December 31, 2022.
  • The Minister may direct the WSIB to provide information the Minister considers necessary to administer the Act. The WSIB must provide it by the deadline and in the form the Minister specifies.
  • The Minister may delegate that information power to the Deputy Minister.

What it means for you#

  • Employers: For the period when the special rule applied, premiums were calculated only on each worker’s earnings up to the applicable limit. The limit was $97,308 unless regulations set another amount.
  • Workers: The bill does not directly change workers’ benefits or duties in the provisions provided.
  • WSIB: The Board must provide information when directed by the Minister, by the deadline and in the form set by the Minister.
  • Minister and Deputy Minister: The Minister may direct the Board to provide information; the Minister may delegate that power to the Deputy Minister.
  • Current status: The special premium rule was temporary. The bill and explanatory note do not show whether regulations changed its amount or extended it. The parent Act and regulations were not supplied, so I cannot verify the current premium rules or other current-law safeguards.

Money#

The available material gives no estimate of the bill’s effect on premium revenue, public spending, or administrative costs.

  • The earnings limit could reduce an employer’s premiums for workers whose average earnings exceeded the applicable limit, but the material gives no total or employer-level estimate.
  • The bill requires the WSIB to provide information when directed, but gives no estimate of the cost or staff time involved.
  • No new tax, fee, fine, or appropriation is set out in the provided text.

What is unclear#

  • The material does not show whether regulations prescribed a different earnings limit or extended the special rule, or what amount applied in practice.
  • The supplied text does not include the Act’s definition of “average earnings” or the wider premium calculation rules.
  • The Minister decides what information is necessary, its deadline, and its form. This section does not set out a process for the Board to challenge a direction.
  • The supplied text does not explain what safeguards or limits elsewhere in the Act may apply to the information power.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the temporary earnings limit is that it capped the earnings used to calculate employer premiums during the specified period.
  • The power to request information could help the Minister administer the Act, and the bill requires the Board to provide information by the set deadline.
  • Allowing regulations to set a different amount or extend the rule—within the stated maximum date—gave the government some flexibility.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain why it chose the $97,308 limit or how any change to that limit would be decided.
  • A limit on earnings used for premiums could affect the revenue collected through those premiums; the material gives no estimate of that effect.
  • The information power leaves the Minister to decide what information is necessary and when and how it must be provided. This section does not spell out further limits or a review process.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2021041302

    Passed66 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 238

    FOR · 50AGAINST · 16

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    50For

    • PC50

    16Against

    • NDP11
    • Liberal3
    • Green1
    • Independent1
  2. Division No. 2021022501

    Passed53 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 238

    FOR · 39AGAINST · 14

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    39For

    • PC35
    • Liberal3
    • Green1

    14Against

    • NDP14