Summary#
Bill 123, the Labour Relations Amendment Act (Replacement Workers), 2022, would amend Ontario’s Labour Relations Act, 1995 by adding rules for strikes and lock-outs. Its stated goal is to restore replacement-worker provisions that the bill’s explanatory note says were repealed in 1995. The bill would take effect on Royal Assent.
- Employers generally could not use specified replacement workers to do striking or locked-out employees’ work. The ban covers people hired or engaged after bargaining notice or the start of bargaining, certain people moved between work sites, and people supplied by another employer.
- Employers could use replacement workers only for listed services—such as emergency dispatch and residential care—or to prevent danger to life, health or safety, serious damage to machinery or premises, or serious environmental damage. Their use would be limited to what is necessary, and the employer would usually have to notify the union and give it a chance to offer willing and able bargaining-unit employees instead.
- The bill would prohibit employers from requiring employees at the strike or lock-out site to do striking employees’ work without their agreement, and from punishing someone for refusing that work.
- After a strike or lock-out, employers would generally have to reinstate employees to their previous positions, subject to rules for limited work, seniority and starting up operations.
- A union could tender payments to continue employment benefits other than pensions. The employer or other obligated person would have to accept sufficient payments and take steps to continue those benefits.
What it means for you#
- Employers: The bill would restrict who you can use to do struck or locked-out work. If you seek to use replacement workers for an allowed service or to prevent specified harm, you would generally have to notify the union, provide details and give it a reasonable chance to offer bargaining-unit employees. In an emergency, you could use replacement workers temporarily while giving notice and checking for consent.
- Unions and striking or locked-out employees: A union could apply to the Labour Relations Board for directions about whether an exception applies and how far replacement workers may be used. Employees would generally have a right to return to work under the bill’s reinstatement rules. A union could also pay to continue covered employment benefits.
- Employees asked to do struck work: You could not be required to do that work without agreement, and the employer could not take the listed forms of reprisal for refusing.
- The public: The exceptions include certain care, shelter, emergency and dispatch services, and measures to prevent specified harm. The bill does not guarantee that all such services would continue at a particular level.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires no stated appropriation and gives no estimate of public, employer or union costs.
- A union that wants covered benefits continued would have to tender enough payment; the employer or other obligated person would have to accept it and take steps to continue the benefits.
- The bill gives the Labour Relations Board added decisions and directions to make, but the available material does not estimate any resulting costs.
What is unclear#
- The Labour Relations Act, 1995, as it currently stands was not supplied, so the bill’s changes could not be checked against the full current law. The explanatory note says the bill restores earlier provisions.
- The bill does not define some important standards, including “reasonable opportunity,” “serious environmental damage” and how much replacement work is “necessary.”
- It sets no timelines for Board decisions. It also does not say who may bring every kind of application or complaint mentioned.
- The exception list refers to a person described in another part of the Act that was not supplied, so that cross-reference could not be verified.
- No publicly available information explains how the added Board work would be funded or staffed.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to stop employers from using replacement workers in ways that could weaken a strike or lock-out.
- A general restriction, paired with specific exceptions for care and emergency services and to prevent serious harm, could protect workers’ bargaining position while allowing limited work needed for safety.
- The union-notice and consent process could give bargaining-unit employees who are willing and able priority for allowed work.
- Reinstatement and benefit-continuation rules could give employees clearer protections during and after a labour dispute.
Case against#
- The restrictions could limit employers’ ability to keep operations running during a strike or lock-out, including where the listed exceptions do not apply.
- The bill leaves key standards open to interpretation. Disagreements about whether an exception applies could require Board decisions.
- It does not estimate the costs of complying with the rules, keeping benefits in place or handling added Board proceedings.
- The reinstatement rules may require employees who performed work during a dispute to yield to returning employees, subject to the bill’s seniority and work-availability rules.