Summary#
Bill 136, the Provincial Animal Welfare Services Act, 2019, was enacted as Chapter 13 of Ontario’s 2019 statutes. It creates a new animal-welfare law, repeals the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act and makes related changes to other laws. Its stated goal is to protect animals; that goal is not a guaranteed result. Most of the Act was to start on a date set by proclamation, and the supplied material does not give those start dates.
- The Minister appoints a Chief Animal Welfare Inspector. The Chief appoints and oversees animal welfare inspectors, who must be public-sector employees and are peace officers when enforcing the Act.
- People who own or care for animals must meet care standards and administrative requirements set by regulation. The Act also bans causing or permitting distress, with exceptions including certain agricultural and veterinary activities.
- Inspectors may investigate and inspect, order owners or custodians to relieve distress, and in specified circumstances take animals into care. They have warrant requirements and limits on entry to dwellings, with an emergency exception for critical distress.
- The Act prohibits animal fighting and harming law-enforcement or service animals. It also allows regulations to set rules for prohibited and restricted animals, certain activities, procedures and items; those lists and rules are not set out in the Act itself. Orca possession and breeding are prohibited, with a limited transition exception.
- Owners or custodians may have to pay for care and treatment. The Act also provides for appeals, offences, fines and—in some cases—animal forfeiture.
What it means for you#
- Animal owners and custodians: You would have to follow the applicable care standards and administrative requirements and not cause or permit distress. Inspectors can order steps to relieve distress, including veterinary examination or treatment at your expense. You can appeal certain orders and decisions to the Animal Care Review Board.
- Veterinarians: You must report suspected abuse, neglect or other listed harm if you have reasonable grounds to believe it is happening. The reporting rules are to be set by regulation.
- People and organizations involved in animal-related activities: Depending on future regulations, some animals may be prohibited or require authorization to possess or breed; some activities may also require authorization or be prohibited. The Act does not itself name those animals or activities, apart from the orca ban.
- Taxpayers and public bodies: The system relies on a Chief Inspector, inspectors employed by public-sector bodies and a continued review board. The Act does not itself say how many inspectors there will be or how the work will be divided.
- People affected by enforcement: The Act provides review of certain decisions, but also gives inspectors enforcement powers. A dwelling generally requires consent or a warrant; an inspector may enter one without a warrant in specified urgent cases involving an animal in critical distress.
- Current-law comparison: The supplied material says the former Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act is repealed and includes transition rules. The former Act was not supplied, so its rules and the full change from that system could not be verified.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Act requires the Chief Inspector to arrange care for animals in the Chief Inspector’s care; it does not estimate the public cost or required staffing.
- Owners or custodians can be liable for care costs. Regulations may set fees for certain authorizations, but no fees are set in the supplied text.
- Maximum fines include up to $130,000 for an individual’s first major offence and $500,000 for a corporation’s first major offence. Some listed offences have a minimum $25,000 fine. These are penalties, not estimates of revenue.
What is unclear#
- Which care standards, administrative requirements, prohibited or restricted animals, prescribed activities, procedures and items would be set by regulation.
- When each part of the Act took effect. The text says most provisions start on proclamation, but the supplied material gives no proclamation dates.
- How many inspectors and other staff would be needed, how their work would be funded, and how enforcement would be coordinated across public-sector bodies.
- How the Act’s rules would work alongside existing programs and laws beyond the consequential amendments listed in the text.
- What “reasonable and generally accepted practices” in agricultural animal care would mean in particular cases.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to establish a provincial system with a Chief Inspector responsible for appointing, training and directing inspectors.
- A possible argument for the Act is that it sets common duties for animal owners and custodians, while allowing standards to differ by animal, activity or circumstance.
- The inspection and emergency powers could allow action when an animal is in distress, while warrants, appeal rights and limits on dwelling entry provide some safeguards.
- The Act sets direct prohibitions on animal fighting and causing or permitting animal distress, and allows courts to impose fines, care-cost orders and bans on keeping animals.
Case against#
- Important rules—including many care standards, animal lists and authorization conditions—are left to future regulations. The Act alone does not show who or what would be covered in those areas.
- Inspectors have broad powers, including taking animals into care and entering a dwelling without a warrant in a specified emergency. A possible concern is whether oversight and review would be enough in difficult cases.
- The system depends on staff and services, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate or staffing plan.
- Some terms and practical details, including how “reasonable and generally accepted” agricultural practices would be applied, are not fully explained in the supplied text.