Bill Cuts Red Tape, Strengthens Animal Safety

Summary#

Bill 46, Less Red Tape, Stronger Ontario Act, 2023, was enacted as Chapter 2 of Ontario’s 2023 statutes. It creates one Act and amends eight others, including laws on animal health, courts, juries, and workplace insurance. Its stated goal is to reduce red tape and strengthen Ontario; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result.

  • The Agriculture Minister may issue urgent animal-health orders, usually for up to 72 hours, with one possible extension of up to 72 hours. People affected must comply when the order takes effect.
  • The Jury Sheriff may send jury questionnaires electronically, but recipients can request a paper copy and people who need accessibility accommodation can request it.
  • Cattle enrolled in Ontario’s Feeder Cattle Loan Guarantee Program are excluded from a stable keeper’s lien for boarding and care charges under the Innkeepers Act.
  • The law removes a statutory ban on certain carbon-sequestration injections. It does not itself approve an injection project.
  • The bill continues the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals as a corporation and gives the Minister power to make regulations about its governance.
  • Other changes set a formula for calculating an injured apprentice’s average earnings, change some Workplace Safety and Insurance Board rules, and create a process to apply to have certain convictions struck out.

What it means for you#

  • People affected by animal-health orders: You must follow an order once it is published or you receive notice, whichever comes first, unless the order says otherwise. Orders may restrict movement or transport of animals and related items, set animal-housing rules, or require biosecurity measures. The Chief Veterinarian may grant an exemption if the order allows it.
  • People selected for jury questionnaires: You must complete and submit the questionnaire within 30 days. If sent electronic access instructions, you can request a paper questionnaire within 10 days. You can also request accessibility accommodation within 10 days; the 30-day period then runs from when you receive the accommodation.
  • Cattle owners and keepers: Cattle enrolled in the loan guarantee program are not subject to the specified Innkeepers Act lien. The bill does not change ownership of the cattle or the program’s loan terms.
  • Apprentices with a work injury: The Workplace Safety and Insurance Board must base average earnings on those of a journeyperson in the same trade employed by the apprentice’s employer, or, if there is none, a journeyperson in the employer’s locality.
  • People with certain provincial-offence convictions: A defendant convicted without a hearing may apply to have the conviction struck out within 15 days after learning of it, on specified grounds such as being unable to attend or not receiving a related notice. The new process took effect six months after Royal Assent.
  • General public: The changes also affect court administration, the Society’s governance, and the Workplace Safety and Insurance Board. The bill does not create a new independent animal-welfare organization.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires existing officials, including the Jury Sheriff and the Chief Veterinarian, to carry out new or changed duties, but gives no cost estimate or staffing figure.
  • It makes no stated appropriation and sets no new tax, fee, or fine.
  • No estimate is given for the financial effects of the apprentice earnings formula or the other changes.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “specific hazards” for temporary animal-health orders or set out a process for people to challenge an order.
  • The Minister may make regulations about the Society’s purposes, membership, board, powers, and possible dissolution. Those details are not set out in the Act itself. The Act says its repeal will take effect on a day set by proclamation; no date is given in the material.
  • The carbon-sequestration change removes a prohibition in the Oil, Gas and Salt Resources Act, but the supplied material does not explain what other approvals or limits apply.
  • The supplied material does not explain the full scope of the Ontario Energy Board exemption changes or how they interact with other rules.
  • The courts provision temporarily raised the annual part-time service limit for former provincial judges from 50% to 75% until April 1, 2024, when it returned to 50%. The material does not explain the practical effect of repealing the separate rule for certain former civil-division judges.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the animal-health order power is that it lets the Minister require immediate, targeted measures when delay is likely to substantially increase health risks. Orders are limited in area and time, and an extension requires the Chief Veterinarian’s recommendation.
  • Electronic questionnaires may give the Jury Sheriff another way to send and receive information, while paper copies and accessibility accommodation remain available on request.
  • The apprentice formula gives the Board a stated method for calculating average earnings instead of leaving that calculation open under the previous wording.
  • Excluding enrolled cattle from the lien may help protect cattle involved in the loan guarantee program from being held for boarding charges.

Case against#

  • Animal-health orders can impose immediate movement, housing, or biosecurity requirements. The bill allows some orders to include other restrictions or requirements the Minister considers necessary, while leaving key terms and challenge procedures unclear.
  • The bill removes a statutory bar on certain carbon-sequestration injections without setting out in this text what safeguards or approvals will apply instead.
  • Important rules for the Society are left to future regulations, including rules about its powers, governance, and possible dissolution.
  • The bill adds duties and changes financial calculations, but the available material gives no cost estimates or staffing details.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2022120101

    Passed103 members voted

    Motion for closure on the motion for Second Reading of Bill 46

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 29

    74For

    • PC73
    • Independent1

    29Against

    • NDP23
    • Liberal6