Health Travel Grant Advisory Committee Act

Summary#

Bill 144, the Northern Health Travel Grant Advisory Committee Act, 2019, would create a new Act, not amend an existing one. It would require the Minister of Health to set up an advisory committee and require the committee to recommend ways to improve travel-cost reimbursement for people in Northern Ontario; improving access to health services is the bill’s stated goal, not a guaranteed result.

  • The Minister must establish the committee within 60 days after the Act receives Royal Assent. The Minister chooses members believed able to contribute, including travel grant recipients and health care providers working in Northern Ontario.
  • The Minister must make reasonable efforts to have the committee reflect Northern Ontario’s diversity, particularly women, Indigenous people, racialized groups, people with disabilities, seniors, and people of diverse sexual orientation, gender identity and gender expression.
  • The committee must examine nine areas, including reimbursement rates, service standards, which health services qualify, pre-payment, direct payment to lodging and transportation providers, travel companion accommodation costs, proof of expenses, and review of program rules and policies. It may make recommendations on these matters.
  • The committee must consult all relevant stakeholders, including primary care providers (Community Health Centres, Aboriginal Health Access Centres, Nurse Practitioner-Led Clinics and Family Health Teams); the Ontario Medical Association; Northern Ontario School of Medicine; Association of Ontario Midwives; Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada; Canadian Institute for Health Information; Ontario Autism Coalition; each Northern Ontario public health unit; and provincial health agencies, including Cancer Care Ontario or its successor and Northern Ontario Local Health Integration Networks or their successors.
  • The committee must report to the Minister within six months of being established. Within 90 days after receiving the report, the Minister must tell the Assembly which recommendations they will implement. The bill does not require the Minister to implement any particular recommendation.

What it means for you#

  • Northern Ontario residents who use the grant: The bill would not itself change grant eligibility, reimbursement amounts, or application rules. It would require an advisory committee to examine possible changes.
  • Grant recipients and Northern Ontario health care providers: They are among the groups from which committee members must be drawn. The bill does not say how many members there will be or how they will be chosen.
  • Listed organizations and health agencies: The committee must consult them, as well as all other relevant stakeholders. The bill does not set out how those consultations must happen.
  • People in Northern Ontario generally: The bill creates an advisory process, not a new travel service or a right to reimbursement at a particular rate.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The Minister must establish the committee, but the bill gives no staffing or budget estimate.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set committee members’ pay and expense payments by regulation; the bill does not require such payments or set amounts.
  • The bill does not itself increase grant payments or authorize a specific amount of spending.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not specify committee size, member selection rules, or how the Minister will decide who can contribute usefully.
  • It does not define “all relevant stakeholders” or set consultation methods.
  • It does not set a response process, review rights, or service standards for grant applications. It asks the committee to examine some of these matters, but does not establish them.
  • The bill does not say what happens if the Minister chooses not to implement recommendations, beyond requiring the Minister to inform the Assembly of which ones they will implement.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address concerns stated in its preamble about customer service, coverage and reimbursement rates in the Northern Health Travel Grant.
  • A committee that must consider actual travel and accommodation costs, service standards and possible payment changes could give the Minister advice across several parts of the program.
  • Requiring consultation with named health organizations and efforts to include diverse residents could bring a range of experiences into the recommendations.

Case against#

  • The committee only advises. The bill does not guarantee changes to reimbursement, eligibility, service standards or the claims process.
  • The bill sets short deadlines for creating the committee and delivering its report, but does not specify its resources or how it should assess the issues.
  • The Minister must report which recommendations they will implement, but the bill does not require any particular recommendation to be adopted or set a deadline for carrying out those selected.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2019120501

    Passed83 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 144

    FOR · 83

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    83For

    • PC51
    • NDP30
    • Green1
    • Independent1

    0Against