Summary#
Bill 13, titled the Northern Health Travel Grant Advisory Committee Act, 2024, would enact a new law, not amend an existing Act. It would require the Minister of Health to set up an advisory committee to recommend ways to improve travel-cost reimbursement for people in Northern Ontario; improving access is the bill’s stated goal, not a guaranteed result. The supplied bill text gives the Act’s short title as the 2022 Act, which conflicts with the 2024 title provided.
- The Minister must establish the committee within 60 days after the Act receives Royal Assent. It must include travel-grant recipients and Northern Ontario health-care providers.
- The Minister must make reasonable efforts to include people reflecting Northern Ontario’s diversity, specifically women, Indigenous people, racialized groups, people with disabilities, seniors, and people of diverse sexual orientation, gender identity and gender expression.
- The committee must examine nine areas, including reimbursement rates, service standards, covered health services, pre-payment, direct payment to travel or lodging providers, travel-companion accommodation costs, proof of expenses, and review of grant rules and policies. It may make recommendations on those matters.
- The committee must consult relevant stakeholders, including primary care providers (Community Health Centres, Aboriginal Health Access Centres, Nurse Practitioner-Led Clinics and Family Health Teams); the Ontario Medical Association; Northern Ontario School of Medicine; Association of Ontario Midwives; Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada; Canadian Institute for Health Information; Ontario Autism Coalition; each Northern Ontario public health unit; and provincial health agencies, including Cancer Care Ontario and Northern Ontario Local Health Integration Networks or their successors.
- The committee must report to the Minister within six months after it is established. Within 90 days of receiving the report, the Minister must tell the Legislative Assembly which recommendations the Minister will implement.
What it means for you#
- People who use the Northern Health Travel Grant: The bill would create a process for recommendations about the grant. It would not itself change who qualifies, what expenses are covered, reimbursement rates, or how claims are handled.
- People and organizations named for consultation: The committee must consult them, but the bill does not require them to accept recommendations or take other action.
- Taxpayers: The bill allows regulations to set committee members’ pay and expenses. It does not set the amounts.
- Northern Ontario residents: The bill defines Northern Ontario as the districts of Algoma, Cochrane, Kenora, Manitoulin, Nipissing, Parry Sound, Rainy River, Sudbury, Thunder Bay and Timiskaming.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- Regulations may set committee members’ remuneration and expenses, but no amounts or overall budget are provided.
- The bill does not set new grant rates or authorize a specific amount of grant spending.
What is unclear#
- The supplied bill text uses a 2022 short title, while the provided bill title says 2024; the materials do not explain the difference.
- The bill does not define “reasonable,” “realistic” or “efficient” reimbursement.
- The Minister must report which recommendations will be implemented, but is not required to implement any recommendation.
- The bill does not set rules for selecting members beyond the stated requirements and the Minister’s view of who can contribute usefully. It also does not say how the committee’s work will be staffed or funded.
- The current grant rules and how this committee’s recommendations would interact with them could not be verified from the supplied material.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to examine stated concerns about customer service, coverage and reimbursement rates in the existing grant program.
- A committee with grant recipients, health-care providers and required consultations could bring different experiences and knowledge into recommendations.
- The required deadlines would set a timetable for recommendations and for the Minister to tell the Assembly which ones will be implemented.
Case against#
- The bill creates a recommendation process, not a requirement to improve reimbursement, expand coverage or change service standards.
- It does not set a budget, require payment of particular expenses, or say how much committee members may be paid.
- The Minister has discretion over who is appointed, while the requirement to reflect Northern Ontario’s diversity is to make “all reasonable efforts”; the bill does not specify how that would be assessed.