Transportation Systems Advisory Committee Bill

Summary#

Bill 136, the Transportation Systems Improvement Advisory Committee Act, 2017, would create a new Act. It would require three provincial officials to establish an advisory committee within 60 days after Royal Assent. The bill’s stated goal is to develop recommendations on highway incident management, accessible parking and technology for safer, more accessible transportation.

  • The Minister of Transportation, the Minister of Community Safety and Correctional Services, and the Commissioner of the Ontario Provincial Police must establish the committee.
  • The committee must include people with relevant expertise and representatives of groups such as municipalities, police, emergency medical services, road users and people with disabilities.
  • The committee must analyze highway incident management and develop a comprehensive improvement program. It must also examine accessible parking and consider how technology could improve safety and access.
  • Within eight months of the committee’s establishment, it must report recommendations on public education, incident detection and clearance, driver information, highway safety, accessible parking and technology.
  • Within 60 days after receiving the report, each minister must tell the Legislative Assembly which recommendations they will implement. The bill does not require them to implement any recommendations.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set committee members’ pay and expense payments by regulation.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers and the public: The committee must consider ways to improve highway incident response and driver information. The bill does not itself change road rules or create a new highway service.
  • People with disabilities: The committee must inquire into accessible parking and recommend on a system that is economically feasible and fair to their interests. The bill does not itself change parking eligibility, permits or rules.
  • Municipalities, police, emergency medical services and other road users: Their representatives must be among the kinds of people considered for committee membership. The bill does not guarantee that any particular organization or person will be appointed.
  • Government: The three named officials must establish the committee. The two ministers must report which recommendations they will implement, but the bill does not set a deadline for putting those recommendations into effect.

Money#

The bill requires a committee to be established, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set members’ remuneration and expense payments; the bill does not require that payments be set.
  • The bill provides no funding amount and does not state how the committee’s work would be staffed or resourced.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set the committee’s size, selection process, term or working procedures.
  • It does not require the committee to consult the public or publish its report. The report must go to the two ministers.
  • The ministers must identify recommendations they will implement, but need not explain why they will not implement others or say when implementation will happen.
  • The bill does not say how the committee’s work would relate to existing accessible-parking or highway-safety programs.
  • The cost of the committee and any member payments are not stated.

Case for#

  • A committee could bring transportation, policing, emergency response, accessibility and technical expertise together to examine connected highway problems.
  • A report with recommendations on driver education, incident detection and clearance, and timely information could give the ministers options for improving incident management.
  • Including people who represent disability interests and people with accessibility expertise could help ensure accessible parking is considered alongside safety and economic feasibility.
  • The bill gives the committee a deadline, and requires the ministers to tell the Assembly which recommendations they will implement.

Case against#

  • The committee is advisory. The bill does not require the ministers to implement its recommendations, so the work may not lead to changes.
  • The bill does not require the ministers to explain which recommendations they reject or set a timeline for carrying out those they accept.
  • The committee’s size, selection process and public consultation rules are not specified, leaving important details to the officials establishing it.
  • The bill requires committee work but provides no cost estimate or funding plan.