Summary#
Bill 161, the Smarter and Stronger Justice Act, 2020, is an omnibus law that amends many existing Ontario laws and enacts the Legal Aid Services Act, 2020. Its stated goal is to improve the justice system; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. Different parts took effect on different dates, and some required a later proclamation.
- Legal aid: The new Act continues Legal Aid Ontario as the same corporation, but replaces its governing law. It gives the corporation broad power to choose services and providers, subject to regulations, and lets its board set eligibility rules. The corporation must provide certain specified legal services, including some representation required by a court or the Charter.
- Property linked to unlawful activity: Changes to the Civil Remedies Act, 2001 let the Attorney General seek administrative forfeiture of eligible personal property. If no one disputes the claim within the statutory 120-day period, the property is forfeited to Ontario. The Act also authorizes court-ordered disclosure of records and requires public reporting.
- Class actions: Changes to the Class Proceedings Act, 1992 add stricter tests for some class actions, rules for choosing between overlapping cases, and a one-year deadline to take steps toward certification or face dismissal for delay. They also add rules for notices, settlements, legal fees and third-party funding.
- Court and legal processes: Fee waivers use an “undue hardship” test and may be revoked for abusive conduct. Judicial reviews generally must start within 30 days. Claims against the Crown or its staff alleging misfeasance or bad faith generally need court permission before proceeding.
- Other changes: The Act changes Law Society powers over law firms, recognizes Indigenous people authorized by their communities to solemnize marriages, and makes changes to estates, jury-list privacy, court offices and other justice laws.
What it means for you#
- People seeking legal aid: Legal Aid Ontario may offer a range of services, including advice, representation, dispute resolution and legal information, in areas such as criminal, family, housing, employment and immigration law. The actual services and eligibility rules depend on regulations and board rules. Services are generally without cost, but the corporation may require contributions in some circumstances.
- People involved in a court case or enforcement: A fee waiver may be granted if you cannot afford fees without undue hardship. A judge, deputy judge or case management master may revoke it if your actions are found frivolous, vexatious or an abuse of process. They may also restrict further fee-waiver requests in the same or a related proceeding.
- People with property held by a public body: The Attorney General may seek forfeiture if there is reason to believe eligible property is proceeds of, or an instrument of, unlawful activity. People notified of the proceeding can dispute it by the deadline. If no dispute is received, the property is forfeited to Ontario. The bill provides a damages action for some people who had a reasonable excuse for missing the deadline, subject to conditions.
- People in or considering a class action: Courts must apply new rules on overlapping cases, certification, delay, settlement approval and funding. Class members may receive clearer notices, but the court can approve settlements that bind members who have not opted out.
- People suing the Crown over alleged misfeasance or bad faith: The claim is automatically stayed unless a court grants leave (permission). To get leave, the claimant must show good faith and a reasonable possibility of winning that claim.
- Lawyers and law firms: The Law Society gains powers to regulate firms, investigate former business premises and seek information from former co-workers. The maximum fine for certain licensee misconduct rises from $10,000 to $100,000.
- Indigenous communities: A person recognized by a qualifying Indigenous community or organization may be registered to solemnize marriages. The person is not required to take part if doing so conflicts with their beliefs or the community’s customs and traditions.
Money#
No publicly available information on an overall cost estimate.
- The new legal aid law says required funding is paid from money appropriated by the Legislature. It also requires Legal Aid Ontario to submit an annual budget and maintain a contingency reserve.
- Legal Aid Ontario may require contributions toward legal aid costs in some cases. The amount and circumstances depend on board rules.
- Money from administratively forfeited property goes into a special-purpose account. It may pay Ontario’s related costs and, subject to rules, compensate victims and others or fund other listed purposes.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the parent Acts, so the full current-law baseline and how every amendment interacts with existing provisions could not be verified.
- The legal aid Act leaves key service and eligibility details to later regulations and board rules. The material does not give their final content or an overall funding amount.
- The forfeiture process depends on notice, the 120-day deadline and who the Attorney General believes may have an interest. The material does not show how often disputes or missed notices may arise.
- Some provisions required proclamations or regulations. The supplied material does not give every effective date or all implementing rules.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the legal aid changes is that one corporation can adapt services and provider arrangements to needs and available funds, while still having duties to provide specified services.
- The class-action rules could help courts manage overlapping cases, check settlement fairness and track how awards and settlements are distributed.
- Administrative forfeiture could provide a defined route for dealing with certain property, while requiring notice and giving people a chance to dispute forfeiture.
- The marriage changes recognize Indigenous community authority to identify people who may solemnize marriages.
Case against#
- Legal aid decisions on services, eligibility and contributions depend heavily on future rules. That leaves important details outside the Act itself.
- A property owner or other interest holder could lose property if no dispute reaches the Attorney General by the deadline. The bill’s remedy for a missed deadline is limited by conditions.
- The 30-day judicial-review limit and the leave requirement for some claims against the Crown could make it harder to bring certain cases, even though courts can extend the review deadline and can grant leave.
- Stricter class-action tests and dismissal for delay could end or prevent some proceedings before their claims are decided.