Summary#
Bill 245, the Accelerating Access to Justice Act, 2021, amends several Ontario laws and enacts the Ontario Land Tribunal Act, 2021. Its stated goal is to accelerate access to justice; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. It received Royal Assent and became Chapter 4 of Ontario’s 2021 statutes, but some provisions require a later proclamation to take effect.
- It combines five existing tribunals into the Ontario Land Tribunal (OLT), and changes rules for hearings, appeals, fees and tribunal powers.
- It changes provincial judge appointments: an advisory committee must usually send the Attorney General a ranked list of at least six candidates; the Attorney General may recommend only someone on that list, but may reject a list and seek a new one.
- It lets regulations create an alternative to the usual hearing process for some proposed expropriations, and changes how interest rates on expropriation compensation are set.
- It transfers public-accounting regulation from the dissolved Public Accountants Council to CPA Ontario. Licensed public accountants must be CPA Ontario members.
- It changes rules for wills, powers of attorney and separated spouses’ inheritance rights, and gives courts power to validate some improperly made wills or related documents.
- It also changes court language rights, the Children’s Lawyer’s role in some cases, and information sharing with the Public Guardian and Trustee.
What it means for you#
The Act makes changes across different areas of government and law. It does not set up one new front-line service.
- People using land, planning or environmental tribunals: The OLT takes over the work of five existing tribunals. It can use hearings or other processes, set fees with the Minister’s approval, and waive fees for low-income individuals under its rules. In some proceedings, it may dismiss a case without a hearing after notice and a chance to make written submissions.
- Property owners facing a proposed expropriation: Regulations may establish a process for owners to comment to the approving authority, which must consider the comments and decide whether to proceed. Where that process applies, the usual hearing process does not apply. The Act does not itself set the details of this alternative process.
- People involved in court cases: French-language documents may be filed in courts across Ontario, and a party in a bilingual proceeding may request a translation of a decision regardless of the language they speak. In certain child-related cases, the Children’s Lawyer may investigate, meet with a child, and report to the court; the court receives the report as evidence.
- People making wills or powers of attorney: Remote witnessing is allowed under specified conditions, including having a lawyer or other Law Society licensee as a witness. The Act also allows a court, on application, to validate certain documents that were not properly made if they show the deceased’s intentions.
- Separated spouses and people settling estates: Marriage no longer automatically revokes a will. In specified circumstances, a separated spouse is treated as having died before the person who made the will, or is not entitled to property under the intestacy rules (rules for distributing property when someone dies without a will).
- Public accountants and people seeking their services: CPA Ontario takes over public-accounting regulation and licensing. It must maintain standards covering matters such as education, inspections, discipline and insurance, subject to the Act’s rules for ministerial review.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The OLT may charge fees, with the Minister’s approval, and may waive fees for low-income individuals. No fee amounts are given.
- The OLT Act allows employees to be appointed as necessary, but gives no staffing number or cost estimate.
- CPA Ontario may set licensing fees. The materials do not estimate what those fees will be.
- Expropriation interest rates are changed from fixed rates in the Act to rates set by regulation. No new rates or financial estimates are provided.
What is unclear#
- Some provisions take effect only on a date set by proclamation. The materials do not say which of those provisions have since been proclaimed.
- The bill text does not set out the alternative expropriation process or the interest rates; those depend on regulations.
- The details of OLT procedures will partly depend on its rules and regulations. The Act gives the Tribunal powers over processes, but does not describe how each type of case will be handled.
- The supplied material does not include the parent Acts in full. I could not verify the explanatory note’s description of prior law against the complete current law.
- The bill does not explain how remote witnessing rules will work in every situation where regulations may add requirements.
Case for#
- Combining five tribunals could make it easier to administer cases that now go to separate bodies.
- A ranked list of several judicial candidates, with reasons, could give the Attorney General options while setting a limit on whom they may recommend.
- Remote witnessing and court validation of some documents could help carry out a person’s wishes when ordinary signing rules were not followed.
- Updating inheritance rules for separation could better reflect the circumstances of some spouses at the time of death.
Case against#
- The Attorney General can keep judge-appointment information confidential, and can reject a ranked list and ask for another. That leaves important influence with the Attorney General, while the bill does not require public disclosure of individual candidates’ records.
- For expropriations covered by future regulations, owners may lose the usual hearing process. The Act leaves the alternative process’s safeguards and details to regulations.
- The OLT can dismiss some cases without a hearing, and non-parties generally may make submissions only in writing. These powers may limit participation in some proceedings.
- The new succession rules may not match every separated person’s wishes. Some will-related outcomes depend on whether the legal tests for separation are met, and some improperly made documents depend on a court application and decision.