Summary#
Bill 181, the Supply Act, 2020, created a law authorizing provincial spending and investments for the fiscal year from April 1, 2019, to March 31, 2020. It also repealed two interim appropriation Acts. Its stated purpose was to provide amounts shown in the estimates; it is not a current spending authority, and it was repealed on April 1, 2021.
- It authorized up to CAD $142.49 billion for public-service expenses, including amounts paid from the Consolidated Revenue Fund or recorded as non-cash expenses.
- It authorized up to CAD $4.46 billion for public-service investments in capital assets, loans and other investments, including non-cash investments.
- It authorized up to CAD $286.59 million for expenses of the Legislative Offices.
- The money had to be applied according to the votes and items in the estimates. A ministry given responsibility for a program or activity during that year could incur or record its related expenditure.
What it means for you#
- Provincial ministries: The Act gave legal authority to use the authorized amounts for the 2019–20 fiscal year. It did not require ministries to spend every dollar.
- Legislative Offices: The Act authorized funding for the Office of the Assembly, Auditor General, Chief Electoral Officer and Ombudsman Ontario.
- Taxpayers and the public: It authorized government spending and investments. It did not directly change taxes, create a public benefit, or give individuals a right to funding.
Money#
The Act authorized a total ceiling of CAD $147.25 billion for 2019–20; this is not the amount known to have actually been spent.
- Up to $142.49 billion for public-service expenses.
- Up to $4.46 billion for public-service investments.
- Up to $286.59 million for Legislative Office expenses.
- Actual amounts paid or recorded are not stated in the supplied material. No publicly available information.
What is unclear#
- The supplied text gives totals by ministry and refers to votes and items in the estimates, but does not provide enough detail to assess every program allocation.
- It does not say how much of the authorized amounts was actually spent, paid out or recorded as non-cash expenses or investments.
- The Act’s authorization covered a past fiscal year and was repealed in 2021; it does not provide ongoing authority.
Case for#
- A government needs legal authority to use public funds. This Act supplied that authority for the stated fiscal year.
- Requiring the money to follow the votes and items in the estimates tied the authority to approved budget allocations.
- The Act separately set out public-service expenses, investments and Legislative Office expenses.
Case against#
- The authorized ceiling was very large, while the supplied material does not show enough detail to judge all program-level allocations.
- The authorization allowed spending or recording amounts up to the limits; the text does not show actual spending or what results the money produced.
- Some authorization covered supplementary estimates, but the supplied material does not explain the specific purposes behind each supplementary amount.