Unpaid leave for infectious disease emergencies

Summary#

Bill 186, the Employment Standards Amendment Act (Infectious Disease Emergencies), 2020, amends Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 and repeals the SARS Assistance and Recovery Strategy Act, 2003. It has been enacted and came into force on Royal Assent. Its stated goal is to set out when employees can take unpaid leave during infectious disease emergencies.

  • Employees are entitled to unpaid leave when they cannot do their job for specified reasons related to an infectious disease designated by regulation. The leave starts on a date set by regulation.
  • Reasons include medical investigation or treatment, quarantine or isolation, an employer’s direction to stay away from work, caring for specified people, and being unable to return to Ontario because of travel restrictions. Other reasons may be added by regulation.
  • Employers may ask for reasonable evidence of entitlement, but cannot require a certificate from a qualified health practitioner for this infectious-disease leave.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may designate diseases and leave start dates, set special rules for police officers, and exempt classes of employees or set different rules for them.
  • The Act also revises rules for leave during declared emergencies. The bill does not create a paid benefit.

What it means for you#

  • Employees: If a designated infectious disease prevents you from doing your job for one of the listed reasons, you are entitled to unpaid leave while the conditions for eligibility continue. The leave is not available under this provision for every infectious disease automatically; the disease must be designated by regulation.
  • Employees providing care: The people you can care for include listed relatives and a person who considers you like a family member, if prescribed conditions are met. The bill does not set those conditions itself.
  • Employers: You may request evidence that is reasonable in the circumstances, but cannot demand a health-practitioner certificate for this leave.
  • Police officers and their employers: Regulations may make the leave provisions apply to police, with special terms and conditions. The bill does not itself set those special rules.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new independent agency, a paid leave benefit, or a tax or fee. It repeals the named SARS Act.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated public cost or employer compliance costs.

  • The leave is without pay, so the bill does not require employers to pay wages for the time taken under this leave provision.
  • The bill sets no spending amount, staffing requirement, fee, or fine. It does give the government power to make regulations, but the materials provide no cost estimate for putting those rules into effect.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not name the infectious diseases covered; regulations must designate them and set the leave start date. No publicly available information on those regulations is included in the supplied material.
  • The bill does not set an application process, decision timelines, appeal process, or reporting requirements for this leave.
  • The bill allows regulations to exempt employee classes or set different rules, but does not identify which classes will be affected.
  • The Employment Standards Act, 2000 and the repealed SARS Act were not supplied in full, so the previous rules and the repeal’s practical effect could not be checked against current law.
  • The bill does not say how the government will fund or administer any regulations it makes.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that employees who cannot work for specific disease-related reasons get a clear legal entitlement to unpaid leave.
  • The listed reasons cover more than an employee’s own illness: they include following public-health directions, an employer’s direction, caring for specified people, and travel restrictions.
  • Not allowing employers to demand a health-practitioner certificate for this leave may make it easier for employees to establish entitlement when the bill’s conditions are met.

Case against#

  • The leave is unpaid. Employees who use it may lose wages, and the bill does not create an income replacement benefit.
  • The government has wide rule-making powers over which diseases qualify, when leave starts, and whether some employee groups face different rules or exemptions. The bill does not set those choices out in detail.
  • The bill does not provide a process for resolving disagreements about eligibility or what evidence is reasonable, leaving important practical details unsettled.