Workplace COVID-19 Presumption Bill Would Aid Workers

Summary#

Bill 191, the Workplace Safety and Insurance Amendment Act (Presumption Respecting COVID-19), 2020, would amend Ontario’s Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, 1997 by adding a COVID-19 presumption for workers at businesses listed as essential. Its stated goal is to set a presumption for COVID-19 claims involving those workers.

  • If a covered worker receives a positive COVID-19 test, the disease would be presumed to be an occupational disease caused by the nature of the worker’s work, unless the contrary is shown.
  • The rule would apply to positive tests received on or after January 25, 2020, whether the person works as an employee or otherwise. It would apply regardless of when the business was listed as essential.
  • The Workplace Safety and Insurance Board and the Workplace Safety and Insurance Appeals Tribunal must decide pending claims under the new rule.
  • Earlier denials would be vacated (cancelled), and the worker could refile the claim. The bill would take effect on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Workers at listed essential businesses: A positive COVID-19 test within the covered dates would trigger the presumption that the disease was work-related. The presumption could be rebutted; it would not by itself guarantee benefits.
  • Workers with claims already in the system: Pending claims would have to be decided using the new rule. If a claim had already been denied, the denial would be vacated and the worker could refile.
  • The Board and Appeals Tribunal: They would have to apply the presumption to covered claims.
  • Employers and the public: The bill does not create a new employer duty, fee, or COVID-19 prevention rule.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not set out an appropriation, cost estimate, new fee, or tax.
  • The presumption could affect which claims qualify for benefits, but the material gives no estimate of resulting payments or savings.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so the bill’s change cannot be fully compared with current claim rules.
  • The bill does not define “positive test” or explain what evidence would show the presumption is rebutted.
  • It does not set out a process or timeline for deciding refiled claims.
  • The bill relies on which businesses were listed as essential in orders under the Emergency Management and Civil Protection Act; the supplied material does not list those businesses.

Case for#

  • The presumption could make it easier for workers in essential businesses to establish that COVID-19 was work-related when the source of infection may be hard to prove.
  • Applying the rule to pending claims and allowing denied claims to be refiled could give workers a way to have claims considered under the new standard.
  • The rule covers people working for a business as employees or otherwise, rather than limiting it to employees.

Case against#

  • The presumption could treat an infection as work-related even when it came from outside work. The bill allows the presumption to be rebutted but does not explain how.
  • The bill does not specify how the Board or Tribunal should assess evidence, leaving those details unclear from the supplied material.
  • The material gives no estimate of the cost of claims that may qualify under the presumption.