Bill expands mental-health claims for essential workers

Summary#

Bill 267, the Workplace Safety and Insurance Amendment Act (Access to Mental Health Support for Essential Workers), 2021, would amend Ontario’s Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, 1997. Its stated goal is to make it easier for certain workers to qualify for benefits for chronic or traumatic mental stress connected with their employment during the COVID-19 pandemic.

  • For covered workers who would otherwise qualify for benefits, the bill would presume their mental stress arose out of and in the course of their employment. The presumption could be disproved; it would not guarantee benefits.
  • Coverage would include people who worked at any time during the pandemic for a business Ontario listed as essential or otherwise considered essential, as well as people in a lengthy list of named jobs and services.
  • The named list includes health care, pharmacies and medical supplies; police and other law enforcement; courts, Indigenous justice and victim services; corrections and probation; fire, paramedic, emergency and forensic services; child care, schools in specified situations, and services for children and people with disabilities.
  • It also includes retirement and long-term care homes; food, farming and supply chains; utilities, water, wastewater and waste services; transportation, shelters and specified hotels; and other listed public, community and private-sector work. The Lieutenant Governor in Council could add individuals by regulation.
  • Eligible claims filed from January 25, 2020 would receive the presumption if pending when the bill became law. Earlier denials would be vacated, and workers could refile.

What it means for you#

  • Covered workers: You would still need to meet the other rules for benefits under the insurance plan. The new presumption would address whether your mental stress arose out of and in the course of your employment—not establish every part of eligibility.
  • Workers with denied or pending claims: If you meet the bill’s coverage and eligibility conditions, a claim filed on or after January 25, 2020 that was still pending when the bill became law would have to be decided using the presumption. A denial made before then would be vacated, and you could refile.
  • Employers and workplaces: The bill does not require employers to provide treatment, create a new mental health service, or require all workers to file claims. It changes how a qualifying claim is assessed.
  • Workers and employers generally: Whether a person is covered may depend on the essential-work categories and the bill’s wording. For example, some work is included only if an employer, municipality, First Nation, or minister makes a specified determination.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state a funding amount, estimate benefit costs, or set out a new fee or tax.
  • The Workplace Safety and Insurance Board and the Appeals Tribunal would have to apply the presumption to covered claims before them. The material gives no estimate of the staff or cost involved.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “otherwise considered essential” or explain how coverage would be decided when a person’s job does not clearly match a listed category.
  • It does not set out new claim forms, decision timelines, appeal rules, or reporting requirements. It does not explain how the presumption would be disproved.
  • The bill does not say how the change would interact with other rules for qualifying for benefits.
  • No start date is stated other than the bill taking effect on Royal Assent. Passage is not certain. The parent Act was not supplied, so its current wording and the bill’s full effect against current law could not be verified.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address the difficulty covered workers may face in showing that chronic or traumatic mental stress arose from their employment during the pandemic.
  • A presumption could reduce that part of the proof required for an otherwise eligible worker’s claim, while still allowing contrary evidence.
  • Applying the rule to pending claims and allowing some denied claims to be refiled could extend the change to earlier claims, rather than only future ones.

Case against#

  • The presumption may make some claims easier to establish even where the connection between the worker’s employment and their mental stress is disputed; the bill does not explain how contrary evidence would be assessed.
  • The coverage list is extensive, and terms such as “otherwise considered essential” are not defined. This could leave uncertainty about who qualifies.
  • The bill does not estimate added benefit or administration costs, or explain how the Board would handle the reopened claims.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2021041202

    Defeated56 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 267

    AGAINST · 41FOR · 15

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    41Against

    • PC41

    15For

    • NDP11
    • Liberal3
    • Green1