Summary#
Bill 6, the Jobs and Jabs Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000; it does not create a new Act. Its stated purpose is to address reprisals (punishment for an employee’s actions or status) related to vaccination information. The bill says its amendments are deemed to have come into force on September 1, 2021.
- Employers and people acting for them could not intimidate, dismiss, place on leave, otherwise penalize, or threaten to penalize an employee because of the employee’s vaccination status or refusal to disclose it.
- “Vaccination status” would mean information about any vaccines given to the employee, not only COVID-19 vaccines.
- The protection would not apply to compliance with requirements under the Child Care and Early Years Act, 2014.
- If an employment standards officer found that an employee was dismissed or terminated in breach of this rule, the officer would have to order reinstatement, as well as any other appropriate remedies under the existing Act.
What it means for you#
- Employees: The bill would protect you from the specified workplace penalties for your vaccination status or for refusing to disclose it, subject to the child-care-law exception. It does not itself require you to disclose your status or prohibit an employer from asking.
- Employers: You would be barred from taking, threatening, or arranging the listed actions for those reasons, except where the child-care-law exception applies. The bill does not itself set vaccination requirements.
- Employment standards officers: If you found a qualifying dismissal or termination, you would have to order reinstatement. The bill also allows other remedies provided for under the existing Act.
- Child-care settings: The exception applies to compliance with requirements under the Child Care and Early Years Act, 2014; the bill does not spell out which situations that covers.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill would require officers to order reinstatement in the specified cases, but gives no estimate for staffing or administrative costs.
- No estimate is provided for costs to employers or any other party.
What is unclear#
- The Employment Standards Act, 2000 was not supplied, so the existing protections, remedies and enforcement process could not be checked against the bill’s changes.
- The supplied material does not establish whether the bill became law or whether its deemed start date took effect.
- The bill does not define “otherwise penalize” or explain how the child-care-law exception applies in particular cases.
- It does not set out a new complaint process, timelines, or appeal rules.
- It does not explain how this protection would interact with other legal requirements or workplace policies.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to protect employees from losing work or facing other penalties because of vaccination information or a refusal to disclose it.
- Requiring reinstatement after a qualifying dismissal could restore an employee’s job, rather than leaving the remedy to a payment alone.
- The child-care-law exception preserves room for compliance with requirements under that Act.
Case against#
- The protection covers information about any vaccines and applies across employment, apart from the stated child-care-law exception. The bill does not explain how it would interact with other requirements.
- The bill does not define “otherwise penalize,” which could leave uncertainty about which employer actions are covered.
- A required reinstatement order leaves the officer no discretion to choose a different remedy for a qualifying dismissal, though other remedies may also be ordered.
- The bill provides no cost estimate or added process details, making its practical and administrative effects hard to assess.