Name Change Ban for Sex Offenders

Summary#

Bill 206, the Change of Name Amendment Act, 2020, would amend Ontario’s Change of Name Act and Christopher’s Law (Sex Offender Registry), 2000. Its stated goal is to make certain offenders ineligible to change their names, subject to exceptions.

  • People required to comply with the sex offender registry would generally be ineligible to change their name. This would also apply to some people who would have to comply but for specified exceptions in Christopher’s Law.
  • People convicted of, or found not criminally responsible for, offences prescribed by regulation would also be ineligible.
  • Regulations could create exceptions and set conditions for them. A separate exception would apply to a name change certified by the Attorney General or an authorized person, and to revoking a name change obtained by fraud, misrepresentation or for an improper purpose.
  • The Registrar General would have to tell an ineligible person the reason for their ineligibility.
  • A ministry employee or authorized person could access the sex offender registry and collect, retain and use information for purposes under the Change of Name Act. They could disclose information to the Registrar General, who could also collect, retain and use it for that Act.

What it means for you#

  • People in the listed groups: You would generally be unable to change your name under the Act, unless a regulatory exception or the Attorney General certification exception applied. The bill does not say it would cancel a name change already completed.
  • People applying for a name change: If you were ineligible, the Registrar General would have to tell you why. The bill does not set out a challenge or appeal process.
  • The Registrar General and ministry staff: The Registrar General would have a new notice duty. Ministry employees or authorized people would have new registry access and information-handling powers.
  • People outside the listed groups: The bill does not directly change your eligibility to change your name.
  • Current law: The Change of Name Act and Christopher’s Law are the Acts being amended, but their full texts were not supplied. I could not verify how the proposed checks or information-sharing would fit with current rules.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Registrar General to give notice to people found ineligible.
  • The bill permits ministry staff and the Registrar General to access or handle registry information for the stated purposes, but gives no staffing or cost estimate and does not set out a funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not list which criminal offences would make a person ineligible; those would be prescribed by regulation.
  • The bill does not list the exceptions or conditions that regulations could create.
  • The bill does not set out how eligibility checks would work, how long they would take, or how a person could challenge a decision. The supplied bill text may not show whether other existing rules address these matters.
  • The bill gives information-access and handling powers but does not itself set out detailed limits or safeguards for that information. The supplied material does not show whether other laws provide them.
  • The changes would start on a date set by proclamation. One transition rule would apply for six months after the main ineligibility provision starts, but the bill text does not give a start date.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent people subject to sex-offender reporting rules, and people convicted of specified offences, from changing their names through the Act.
  • A possible argument for the registry information-sharing power is that it could let the Registrar General check whether an applicant falls into a group barred from changing names.
  • The bill allows exceptions through regulations and includes a route for a name change certified by the Attorney General or an authorized person.

Case against#

  • A broad restriction on name changes could affect people whose circumstances differ, while the bill leaves the list of other covered offences and possible exceptions to future regulations.
  • The bill does not set out a way to challenge an ineligibility decision or explain how errors would be corrected.
  • Registry information could be accessed, collected, retained, used and disclosed for the stated purposes, but the bill itself does not detail limits on that handling.