Summary#
Bill 138, the Change of Name Amendment Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Change of Name Act and Christopher’s Law (Sex Offender Registry), 2000. Its stated goal is to make certain people required to comply with sex-offender registry rules ineligible to apply for a name change.
- People who must comply with the registry rules, and some people who would have to comply but for specified exceptions in Christopher’s Law, would generally be ineligible to apply for a change of name.
- The ineligibility would not apply to a name change certified as described in Change of Name Act subsection 8(2) by the Attorney General or an authorized person. Regulations could also set exceptions, with conditions.
- The Registrar General would have to tell an ineligible applicant that they are ineligible and why.
- Ministry employees or authorized people could access registry information and use it for the name-change law’s purposes. They could disclose it to the Registrar General, who could collect, retain and use it for those purposes.
- Applications or elections submitted before the changes start would remain subject to the earlier law. The bill would start on a date set by proclamation.
What it means for you#
- People applying to change their name: If you fall into one of the bill’s registry-related categories, you generally could not apply. The bill provides for exceptions, but the materials do not explain what the certification under subsection 8(2) involves.
- The Registrar General and ministry staff: The Registrar General would have to notify ineligible applicants and could use registry information for purposes under the Change of Name Act. Ministry employees or authorized people could access and share that information for those purposes.
- Other applicants and the public: The bill does not directly change everyone’s eligibility to change their name, or create a new public-facing service.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s cost is included in the supplied materials.
- The bill would require the Registrar General to notify ineligible applicants and allow ministry staff and the Registrar General to access and handle registry information. No staffing or administrative cost estimate is provided.
What is unclear#
- The supplied materials do not include the current versions of the Acts being amended. I could not verify the existing application rules or the meaning of referenced provisions, including subsections 5.1(1), 6(10) and 8(2).
- The bill does not explain what certification under subsection 8(2) requires, or who could qualify for it.
- Regulations could create exceptions and attach conditions, but the bill does not say what those exceptions or conditions would be.
- The bill does not set out a decision process, timelines or an appeal process for an applicant found ineligible.
- The start date depends on a proclamation. The bill also says its transition rule will be repealed six months after the main ineligibility provision starts.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that preventing some people from changing their names could help keep registry information connected to their identity.
- Allowing ministry staff to check registry information could help identify people covered by the ineligibility rule.
- The bill requires the Registrar General to tell an ineligible applicant the reason, rather than leaving the person without an explanation.
Case against#
- The ineligibility applies broadly to the categories named in the bill, while the available text does not explain how the certification exception would work.
- The bill permits access to, collection, retention and use of sensitive registry information for name-change purposes, but the supplied text does not explain related safeguards or oversight.
- The bill leaves important exceptions and conditions to future regulations. Their scope is not known from the bill text.