Bill bars some name changes for sex offenders

Summary#

Bill 39, the Change of Name Amendment Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Change of Name Act and Christopher’s Law (Sex Offender Registry), 2000. Its stated goal is to make certain offenders ineligible to change their names, subject to exceptions. The supplied material does not establish the bill’s current status; if enacted, it would start on a day named by proclamation.

  • People required to comply with Ontario’s sex-offender registry rules—and certain people who would be required to comply but for specified exceptions in those rules—would generally be ineligible for a name change.
  • People convicted of, or found not criminally responsible for, criminal offences prescribed by regulation would also generally be ineligible.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council could make regulations allowing exceptions, with conditions. The Attorney General or an authorized person could also certify an exception for a change of name.
  • The Registrar General would have to tell an ineligible applicant that they are ineligible and why.
  • Ministry employees or authorized people could access registry information, use it for the name-change screening purpose, and disclose it to the Registrar General. The Registrar General could collect, retain and use it for purposes of the Change of Name Act.

What it means for you#

  • People applying to change their name: If you fall into one of the listed categories, the bill would generally bar a name change under any provision of the Change of Name Act, unless an exception applies. A person who is ineligible must be told why.
  • People seeking a name change certified by the Attorney General: The ineligibility rule would not apply to a change certified by the Attorney General or an authorized person. The bill does not set out how to seek that certification.
  • People whose name change was obtained through fraud, misrepresentation or an improper purpose: The ineligibility rule would not prevent revocation of that change under the Act’s existing revocation provision.
  • Ministry staff and the Registrar General: They would have new authority to access, share and handle sex-offender registry information for the bill’s screening purpose. The Registrar General would also have a duty to notify ineligible applicants.
  • Other members of the public: The bill does not directly change your name-change eligibility unless you fall into a listed category.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill allows registry information to be accessed and handled for name-change screening, but gives no cost, staffing or funding estimate.
  • It does not set a fee or fine.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not name the criminal offences that would trigger ineligibility; regulations would prescribe them.
  • Regulations could set exceptions and conditions, but the bill does not specify what they would be.
  • The bill does not set out the screening process, timelines, or a way to challenge an ineligibility decision. These details may be addressed elsewhere, but the Change of Name Act was not supplied, so that could not be checked.
  • The bill does not state when it would start. The start date would depend on a proclamation.
  • The bill says applications or elections submitted before the main change takes effect would continue under the earlier version of the Act. It also provides for that transition rule to be repealed six months after the main change starts.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent people subject to sex-offender registry requirements, and other specified offenders, from changing their names through the Act.
  • Allowing registry information to be checked and shared for this purpose could help the Registrar General identify whether an applicant falls into a barred category.
  • The bill allows exceptions, including certification by the Attorney General, rather than making the ineligibility rule absolute.

Case against#

  • The bill gives ministry staff or authorized people access to sensitive registry information and allows it to be shared with the Registrar General. The supplied text does not describe additional safeguards or limits beyond the stated purpose.
  • The range of criminal offences covered would depend on regulations, and the bill does not say what those offences would be.
  • The bill does not explain how a person could seek an exception or challenge a decision, or how that process would work.
  • The bill does not provide a cost estimate for the screening and information-handling work it authorizes.