Bill would empower online food restrictions

Summary#

Bill 263, the Health Protection and Promotion Amendment Act (Temptation Be Gone), 2021, would amend Ontario’s Health Protection and Promotion Act. Its stated goal is to permit rules restricting or prohibiting sales and displays of high-fat, high-sodium or high-sugar food; the bill does not itself impose those restrictions.

  • It would let the Lieutenant Governor in Council make regulations restricting or prohibiting the online sale or offering for sale of any food.
  • Regulations could define high-fat, high-sodium or high-sugar food and restrict or prohibit its display or sale at food premises, including at entrances, exits, aisle ends and checkout counters.
  • Regulations could restrict or prohibit selling those foods online, including on website homepages or payment pages.
  • Regulations could restrict or prohibit volume promotions and promotions offering free refills for those foods.
  • Unless regulations are made under both the in-person and online powers for the specified foods, the Minister must table an annual report on progress in developing regulations, including any public consultations.

What it means for you#

  • Food businesses and online sellers: The bill would give the government power to make rules affecting where or how food is displayed or sold. The bill itself does not require businesses to change their practices; restrictions would depend on regulations.
  • Consumers: The bill does not itself ban any food or change what you can buy. Regulations could later limit the display or sale of some foods, and could restrict online sales of any food.
  • The public: The bill creates a regulation-making power and a reporting duty, not a new front-line service or a process for people to apply for decisions.
  • The parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify what related powers or enforcement rules already exist in current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated costs.

  • The bill does not state a budget, funding source, fee, fine or staffing estimate.
  • The bill requires the Minister to table reports in specified circumstances, but does not estimate the cost of preparing them or making regulations.

What is unclear#

  • Regulations would define what counts as high-fat, high-sodium or high-sugar food. The bill does not set those definitions.
  • The bill does not say what restrictions would be adopted, which businesses or websites they would cover, or when they would take effect.
  • Public consultation may be described in the annual report, but the bill does not require consultation.
  • The bill does not specify how the rules would be enforced or what penalties would apply. The parent Act was not supplied, so existing enforcement provisions could not be checked.
  • It is unclear how the broad power over online sales of “any food” would be used alongside the more specific powers for high-fat, high-sodium or high-sugar food.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives the government tools to limit prominent displays and promotions of foods it defines as high in fat, sodium or sugar.
  • It could let regulations address online sales as well as sales at food premises.
  • The annual reporting duty could make the Minister report on progress if regulations under both powers have not been made.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the online power covers any food, not only food defined as high in fat, high in sodium or high in sugar.
  • The bill leaves key choices—including definitions, restrictions and coverage—to later regulations, so its practical effects are not yet clear.
  • It does not require public consultation or set out costs, enforcement details or penalties in the bill itself.