Delivery Noise Rules and Local Food Board Reform

Summary#

The Main Street Recovery Act, 2020 is an enacted Ontario law (Chapter 29 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2020). It amends the City of Toronto Act, 2006, the Highway Traffic Act, the Municipal Act, 2001 and the Ontario Food Terminal Act. Its stated goal is Ontario’s economic recovery.

  • Municipalities, including Toronto, generally cannot prohibit or regulate noise from deliveries to listed businesses and facilities. Regulations may allow them to do so, including in specified areas.
  • Toronto by-laws requiring a licence or other authorization for paid passenger pick-ups are added to the laws drivers must follow. The fine range for the listed offences rises from $300–$20,000 to $500–$30,000.
  • The Ontario Food Terminal Board’s market role expands beyond fruit and produce to a wholesale market primarily for agricultural products, and promoting local food becomes one of its objects.
  • The existing Terminal Board must have 5 to 13 members appointed by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. The Board may appoint a Terminal manager, subject to the Minister’s approval, and may create committees to advise it.
  • The Board may make rules limiting what counts as an agricultural product or designating additional products. The law says products can qualify whether wrapped, packaged or minimally processed.

What it means for you#

  • Municipalities and Toronto: Their power to control delivery noise at retail businesses, restaurants, hotels and motels, and goods distribution facilities is restricted unless a regulation restores or governs that power. The change concerns noise connected with deliveries to those places, not all noise.
  • Drivers carrying passengers for compensation in Toronto: If a Toronto by-law requires a licence, permit or authorization for a pick-up, the Highway Traffic Act now includes that requirement in its licensing rules. A person who has care or control of a motor vehicle is included in the definition of “driver.” The fine for the listed offences is $500 to $30,000 on conviction.
  • Ontario Food Terminal and people dealing in agricultural products: The existing Board can serve a broader product market and must include promoting local food among its objects. The law does not create a new independent body or a direct benefit for local food businesses.
  • General public: The law does not itself set delivery hours, create a noise-complaint process, or establish a new food-purchasing program.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The material gives no estimate of public spending, savings, business costs or revenue from fines.
  • The Board may create committees, but the material does not say whether this will require additional spending.

What is unclear#

  • The delivery-noise changes and the Food Terminal changes take effect on dates set by proclamation. The material does not give those dates or say whether the provisions have since been proclaimed. The Highway Traffic Act changes took effect on Royal Assent.
  • The Minister may make regulations about where and how municipalities can regulate delivery noise, and may define the listed types of places. The material does not say what regulations will be made.
  • The law does not set out how the Food Terminal Board will apply its rules about agricultural products.
  • The full parent Acts were not supplied, so changes to current law could not be independently checked against them beyond the explanatory note.

Case for#

  • The delivery-noise limits could make delivery rules more consistent for businesses and facilities that receive goods.
  • Letting regulations restore municipal powers, including in specified areas, leaves room to set local limits where authorized.
  • A broader agricultural-products mandate could let the existing Food Terminal serve more kinds of products.
  • Making local-food promotion an object gives it an explicit place in the Board’s work.

Case against#

  • Municipalities lose a direct way to prohibit or regulate delivery noise at the listed places unless regulations authorize it. The law does not specify what protections or limits will apply.
  • Important details about noise rules are left to future regulations, including which places or areas may be covered.
  • The Board’s wider product mandate and rule-making powers could change what products the Terminal handles, but the law does not set out how those choices will be made.
  • The fine increase for the listed offences is substantial, while the material does not explain how enforcement or the new Toronto licensing link will work in practice.