Bill limits security notices on consumer goods

Summary#

Bill 169, the Removing Red Tape for Homeowners (No More Pushy, High-Pressure HVAC Scams) Act, 2024, would amend Ontario’s Personal Property Security Act. Its stated goal is to prevent notices of security interests from being registered against homeowners for certain consumer goods. The bill itself does not name HVAC equipment; the Minister would decide which consumer goods are covered by regulation.

  • The registrar must refuse to register a notice of security interest, or an extension of one, when the collateral is a prescribed consumer good.
  • The registrar must discharge existing registrations for those goods, either on the registrar’s own initiative or after a written request from anyone affected by the registration.
  • The Minister may prescribe which consumer goods are covered. The bill does not require the Minister to prescribe any particular goods.
  • The bill changes rules about registering notices. It does not expressly cancel a financing agreement, debt, or underlying security interest.
  • The supplied material does not show the full current Act, so the existing rules and how this change would interact with them could not be verified.

What it means for you#

  • Homeowners and other affected people: If a good is prescribed, a notice of security interest about it could not be registered. An affected person could ask the registrar in writing to discharge an existing registration.
  • Consumers and businesses dealing in covered goods: The registrar would have to discharge existing notices for prescribed goods and refuse new notices or extensions. The text does not set out a process for resolving disputes about whether a good is covered.
  • People financing or supplying goods: The bill does not say that a debt or financing agreement is cancelled when a notice is discharged. It changes the registration of notices, not expressly the underlying agreement or security interest.
  • The Minister and registrar: The Minister may set the list of covered goods. The registrar must carry out the registration ban and discharge rule for goods on that list.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the registrar to discharge covered registrations, but gives no estimate of staffing or other administrative costs.
  • It does not set a fee, fine, payment, or compensation.

What is unclear#

  • Which consumer goods, if any, the Minister would prescribe. The bill does not specifically name HVAC equipment.
  • Whether the Minister would make rules, and when any list of covered goods would take effect.
  • What information or process the registrar would use to identify and discharge existing registrations.
  • Whether there would be a way to challenge a decision about whether a good is covered.
  • How the registration change would affect the rights of people who hold security interests. The bill does not expressly cancel those interests, but the supplied material does not explain their legal effect after a notice is discharged.
  • The bill says it would start on Royal Assent; the supplied material does not say whether it has received Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to stop notices of security interests from being registered against consumers’ goods when those goods are prescribed.
  • Requiring the registrar to discharge existing notices could remove registrations that the bill treats as inappropriate for those goods.
  • Giving affected people a written-request route could let them seek removal without waiting for the registrar to act on its own.
  • Letting the Minister prescribe goods could allow the list to be set through regulation rather than naming every item in the Act.

Case against#

  • The bill does not say which goods would be covered. Without that list, consumers and businesses cannot tell how broad the change would be.
  • The Minister may prescribe goods but is not required to do so, so the bill alone does not ensure that any goods—including HVAC equipment—are covered.
  • Discharging a notice may affect how a security interest is recorded, but the bill does not explain what happens to the underlying rights or how affected parties can challenge a discharge.
  • The bill requires the registrar to discharge existing notices but gives no process, timeline, or cost estimate for doing so.