Summary#
Bill 275, the Supply Chain Management Amendment Act (Provincial Diverse Vendor Strategy), 2021, would amend Ontario’s Supply Chain Management Act (Government, Broader Public Sector and Health Sector Entities), 2019. Its stated goal is to promote the use of diverse vendors and advance inclusion in supply chain management.
- The Standing Committee on Justice Policy must deliver recommendations to the Minister within six months after the bill takes effect. Within that period, the Minister must adopt a business case study on diverse-vendor procurement, then establish an advisory board within one month after receiving the committee’s report.
- The Government of Ontario must develop and implement a Provincial Diverse Vendor Strategy, and the Minister must publish it.
- The Strategy must set out goals and objectives about the proportion of vendors that must be diverse vendors, initiatives to promote inclusion and economic recovery, requirements for public-sector entities, and the business case study’s results.
- A diverse vendor is defined as a vendor business at least 51 per cent owned, operated, managed or controlled by people from one or more historically disadvantaged communities.
- Government, broader public-sector and health-sector entities must comply with requirements in the Strategy. The Minister must report on the Strategy at least yearly; a legislative committee would be empowered, but not required, to review each report.
What it means for you#
- Diverse vendors: The bill does not give businesses a contract, grant or right to be selected. The Strategy would set the goals and requirements, but the bill does not specify how procurement decisions would change.
- Government and public-sector entities: Government entities, broader public-sector entities and health-sector entities must follow requirements later set out in the Strategy. The bill does not itself set those detailed requirements.
- People in communities named in the bill: The Strategy must include initiatives for diverse-vendor candidates disproportionately affected by COVID-19. Examples listed include immigrants, women, LGBTQ2S+ people, people with disabilities, veterans, Indigenous peoples and racialized people. The bill does not promise a particular service or benefit to them.
- Taxpayers and the public: The Minister must publish the Strategy and report on government activities and whether its objectives have been met. The bill does not require a committee to review those reports.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material. No publicly available information.
- The bill gives no funding amount, staffing level or cost estimate for the committee work, business case study, advisory board, Strategy or annual reports.
What is unclear#
- The parent 2019 Act was not supplied, so its current procurement rules and how the bill would interact with them could not be verified.
- “Historically disadvantaged communities” is not defined. The bill also does not explain how the 51 per cent test applies to “owned, operated, managed or controlled.”
- The bill does not set a vendor target, procurement preference, application process, decision rules, timeline or appeal process. Those details may depend on the Strategy or later rules.
- The bill does not say how the advisory board would be composed or what powers or duties it would have; those details may be prescribed later.
- The bill says it would take effect on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not establish whether it became law.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it would require a province-wide plan rather than leaving diverse-vendor procurement without a shared strategy.
- Requiring a business case study and committee recommendations could inform the Strategy’s design.
- Annual public reporting could show what the government did and whether stated objectives were met.
- The Strategy must address inclusion and economic capacity-building for diverse-vendor candidates affected by COVID-19.
Case against#
- The bill leaves the main procurement rules and vendor targets to a future Strategy, so the practical effect is not yet clear.
- Public-sector entities must comply with later Strategy requirements, but the bill does not specify their scope or the resources needed to meet them.
- The definition of diverse vendor uses terms the bill does not explain, which could make eligibility uncertain.
- The bill requires a board and ongoing reports but provides no cost estimate or funding details.