Summary#
Bill 194, the Fairness in Procurement Act, 2018, was enacted as an Ontario law. It allows the province to respond to certain procurement barriers imposed by U.S. jurisdictions by restricting suppliers from those jurisdictions in Ontario public procurement. Its stated goal is to defend Ontario’s economic interests and respond proportionally; that goal is not a guaranteed result.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council may designate a U.S. jurisdiction as “offending” if the Minister believes that jurisdiction has measures that may inhibit or prevent Ontario suppliers from taking part or succeeding in its procurement.
- Regulations may set measures for suppliers from designated jurisdictions, including excluding them from procurement, requiring extra information, or applying stricter evaluation criteria. The regulations determine which suppliers, public buyers, and procurements are covered.
- Government entities and broader public sector entities must comply with applicable regulations. Broader public sector entities include bodies such as hospitals, school boards, and certain post-secondary institutions.
- Regulations may create a process for exemptions. The Act itself does not set out that process.
- A procurement contract entered into by a broader public sector entity is void if the contract or the process for entering it breaches the Act or regulations, unless the Minister validates it. Regulations may also set other sanctions.
- The Act bars claims for compensation or other remedies against the listed public bodies and officials over actions under the Act. The Attorney General may still seek to require compliance.
What it means for you#
- Ontario suppliers: The Act does not itself give Ontario suppliers a new contract or guarantee them access to U.S. procurement. It allows Ontario to respond if a U.S. jurisdiction’s measures meet the Act’s test.
- Suppliers from a designated U.S. jurisdiction: Your participation in covered Ontario public procurement may be restricted, subject to the regulations. The Act does not itself say that every such supplier or procurement will be covered.
- Public buyers: Government entities and broader public sector entities must follow any applicable regulations. A broader public sector entity risks having a non-compliant procurement contract treated as void, unless the Minister validates it.
- General public: The Act does not create a new front-line service or directly change taxes, benefits, or private procurement. Its effects depend on designations and regulations.
Money#
No publicly available information on the Act’s costs or expected savings.
- The Act permits regulations that may require public buyers to provide compliance information or take other measures. It gives no estimate of staffing, administration, or other costs.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not say when the Act came into force or whether any jurisdiction has been designated or regulations made.
- Regulations would determine which suppliers and procurements are covered, how a supplier or buyer is considered to be “from” a jurisdiction, and what restrictions apply.
- The Act allows exemptions but does not set out who may apply, the decision rules, or timelines.
- The Minister may consult before regulations are made, but consultation is not required by the Act. The Act requires each regulation to be reviewed at least once every four years.
- The materials do not give cost estimates or explain how the Act would interact with existing procurement rules.
Case for#
- The Act appears intended to give Ontario a way to respond when another jurisdiction limits Ontario suppliers’ access to public procurement.
- A possible argument for the approach is that responses can be tailored through regulations, rather than automatically applying the same restriction to every supplier or procurement.
- The exemption power could allow exceptions in particular cases, if regulations create a process for them.
Case against#
- The Act leaves the main restrictions to future regulations, so the practical effect depends on decisions and rules not set out in the Act.
- The Act permits measures ranging from extra information requirements to exclusion from procurement. This could limit competition for covered contracts.
- A broader public sector contract that breaches the Act or regulations is void unless the Minister validates it, which could create uncertainty for buyers and suppliers.
- The Act bars compensation and other claims related to its application, while the materials do not explain what review or appeal process would be available to affected suppliers.