Retirement homes regulation shifts to ministry

Summary#

Bill 296, the Retirement Home Justice and Accountability Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Retirement Homes Act, 2010; it would not create a separate new law. Its stated purpose is to dissolve the Retirement Homes Regulatory Authority and have the Ministry perform certain regulatory functions. The bill aims to place those functions within the Ministry; that does not guarantee better enforcement or care.

  • The Retirement Homes Regulatory Authority would be dissolved. The Ministry would have to ensure retirement homes follow the Act and regulations, and educate licensees, consumers and the public about legal requirements, care and safety standards, residents’ rights and operating practices.
  • The Minister would have to appoint a Registrar and a Complaints Review Officer, and could appoint up to two Deputy Registrars. The Registrar would perform duties assigned by the Act and regulations.
  • The Minister would manage the continued Retirement Homes Emergency Fund. Regulations could allow the Registrar to direct payments from the Fund to the Ministry for its work, or direct the Ministry to reduce licence applicants’ or licensees’ fees.
  • The Minister could set fees, costs and other charges for administering the Act or for the Registrar’s work. A person could not be charged for making a complaint under the specified complaint provision.
  • Existing advisory committees that meet the bill’s continuation condition would continue.

What it means for you#

  • Residents, families and other consumers: The Ministry would have to educate consumers and the public about the Act, including residents’ rights. The bill does not itself set out a new complaint or service process.
  • Retirement-home licensees: The Ministry would take on the duty to ensure homes follow the Act and regulations. The Minister could set charges related to administering the law, but not a fee for making the specified kind of complaint.
  • Registrar and people affected by the Registrar’s actions: The Registrar would not have to hold a hearing or give someone an opportunity for one, subject to regulations. The Statutory Powers Procedure Act would not apply to the Registrar’s actions under the Act.
  • Ministry: It would take on regulatory duties and manage the Emergency Fund. The bill does not say how many staff or what resources it would need.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s costs is provided in the supplied materials.

  • The Ministry would have to carry out new or transferred duties, and the Minister would have to appoint a Registrar and Complaints Review Officer. The bill gives no cost estimate or staffing number.
  • The Minister could set fees, costs and charges, and could require interest, penalties and collection costs for late or unpaid amounts. No amounts are specified.
  • Regulations could allow Fund payments to the Ministry for its work, or reductions in fees for licence applicants or licensees. The bill does not specify amounts or when this power would be used.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the full Retirement Homes Act, 2010. I could not verify against current law exactly which Authority functions already exist, or the full effect of the bill’s amendments.
  • The bill does not set out how the Ministry would enforce the Act, handle complaints, or decide when the Registrar should hold a hearing. Regulations could affect the hearing rule.
  • It does not specify how the Ministry would staff or fund its duties, or how the Emergency Fund would be used in practice.
  • It does not explain how the Minister’s fee-setting power would interact with existing fees, or what charges might be set.
  • The bill would come into force six months after Royal Assent, but the supplied materials do not establish whether it became law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that putting enforcement and public education duties in the Ministry could make the government directly responsible for those functions.
  • The Ministry would have to educate licensees and consumers about requirements, residents’ rights and care and safety standards.
  • Continuing the Emergency Fund and advisory committees would preserve those arrangements rather than ending them along with the Authority.

Case against#

  • The Ministry would take on regulatory duties while also managing the Emergency Fund and appointing key officials. The bill does not explain how it would ensure those functions have enough staff or remain independent.
  • The Registrar could act without a hearing, and the usual Statutory Powers Procedure Act would not apply. The bill does not spell out what other procedural protections would apply.
  • The bill permits fees, late penalties and collection costs but does not set amounts or limits in the supplied text.
  • The bill transfers functions, but does not explain the practical process for enforcement, complaints or oversight.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2021053103

    Defeated54 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 296

    AGAINST · 35FOR · 19

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    35Against

    • PC34
    • New Blue Party of Ontario1

    19For

    • NDP12
    • Liberal6
    • Green1