Summary#
Bill 49, the Charter Rights Transparency Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Ministry of the Attorney General Act. Its stated goal is to inform the Legislature and public about how minister-introduced bills may affect Canadian Charter rights and freedoms.
- The Attorney General would have to examine every bill introduced by a minister and every regulation filed with the Registrar of Regulations for provisions more likely than not to be found by a court inconsistent with the Charter.
- If the Attorney General finds such a provision, the Attorney General would have to table a report explaining the inconsistency at the earliest reasonable opportunity.
- For each minister-introduced bill, the Attorney General would also have to table a statement explaining potential Charter effects and how they may arise. It must be tabled before second-reading debate can begin.
- If a bill invokes the Charter’s notwithstanding clause, the examination must also assess whether a provision would likely be found inconsistent without that declaration.
- The bill does not require a government to change or withdraw a bill or regulation found to raise Charter concerns. The current Ministry of the Attorney General Act was not supplied, so I could not verify what review or reporting duties already exist.
What it means for you#
- Attorney General: Must examine the specified bills and regulations, table reports when the stated threshold is met, and provide a Charter-effects statement for every minister-introduced bill.
- Ministers and the Legislature: Second-reading debate on a minister’s bill could not begin until its Charter-effects statement is tabled. The bill does not require the minister to change the bill based on the statement or report.
- People reading or affected by laws: The public and legislators would receive information about potential Charter effects of minister-introduced bills. Regulations would be examined too, but the bill does not require a statement about each regulation.
- Everyone else: The bill does not itself change Charter rights, create a new individual remedy, or prevent a bill or regulation from taking effect.
Money#
No publicly available information on estimated costs.
- The Attorney General would have to carry out examinations and prepare statements and reports. The bill gives no staffing or funding amount.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set out how the Attorney General must conduct the examinations or assess potential effects.
- It does not specify an oversight process or what happens if a required statement or report is not tabled.
- “At the earliest reasonable opportunity” is not given a specific deadline.
- The bill does not say how examination work would be staffed or funded.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that legislators and the public would get information about possible Charter effects before debating minister-introduced bills.
- Reporting likely inconsistencies could make potential rights concerns visible, including for regulations.
- When a bill invokes the notwithstanding clause, examining it without that clause could show what Charter issue the declaration addresses.
Case against#
- The bill requires examination and disclosure, but does not require the government to change a proposal or explain why it proceeds despite a reported concern.
- The Attorney General would conduct the examination; the bill does not require an independent review.
- The bill sets no detailed assessment method, oversight process, or firm deadline for reports. That could leave the scope and timing of the information unclear.