Charter Rights Transparency Act

Summary#

Bill 49, the Charter Rights Transparency Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Ministry of the Attorney General Act. Its stated goal is to inform the Legislature and public about how minister-introduced bills may affect Canadian Charter rights and freedoms.

  • The Attorney General would have to examine every bill introduced by a minister and every regulation filed with the Registrar of Regulations for provisions more likely than not to be found by a court inconsistent with the Charter.
  • If the Attorney General finds such a provision, the Attorney General would have to table a report explaining the inconsistency at the earliest reasonable opportunity.
  • For each minister-introduced bill, the Attorney General would also have to table a statement explaining potential Charter effects and how they may arise. It must be tabled before second-reading debate can begin.
  • If a bill invokes the Charter’s notwithstanding clause, the examination must also assess whether a provision would likely be found inconsistent without that declaration.
  • The bill does not require a government to change or withdraw a bill or regulation found to raise Charter concerns. The current Ministry of the Attorney General Act was not supplied, so I could not verify what review or reporting duties already exist.

What it means for you#

  • Attorney General: Must examine the specified bills and regulations, table reports when the stated threshold is met, and provide a Charter-effects statement for every minister-introduced bill.
  • Ministers and the Legislature: Second-reading debate on a minister’s bill could not begin until its Charter-effects statement is tabled. The bill does not require the minister to change the bill based on the statement or report.
  • People reading or affected by laws: The public and legislators would receive information about potential Charter effects of minister-introduced bills. Regulations would be examined too, but the bill does not require a statement about each regulation.
  • Everyone else: The bill does not itself change Charter rights, create a new individual remedy, or prevent a bill or regulation from taking effect.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated costs.

  • The Attorney General would have to carry out examinations and prepare statements and reports. The bill gives no staffing or funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out how the Attorney General must conduct the examinations or assess potential effects.
  • It does not specify an oversight process or what happens if a required statement or report is not tabled.
  • “At the earliest reasonable opportunity” is not given a specific deadline.
  • The bill does not say how examination work would be staffed or funded.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that legislators and the public would get information about possible Charter effects before debating minister-introduced bills.
  • Reporting likely inconsistencies could make potential rights concerns visible, including for regulations.
  • When a bill invokes the notwithstanding clause, examining it without that clause could show what Charter issue the declaration addresses.

Case against#

  • The bill requires examination and disclosure, but does not require the government to change a proposal or explain why it proceeds despite a reported concern.
  • The Attorney General would conduct the examination; the bill does not require an independent review.
  • The bill sets no detailed assessment method, oversight process, or firm deadline for reports. That could leave the scope and timing of the information unclear.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2018112201

    Defeated74 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 49

    AGAINST · 55FOR · 19

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    55Against

    • PC55

    19For

    • NDP14
    • Liberal4
    • Green1