Summary#
Bill 49, the Transparency and Accountability in Government Contracting Act, 2016, would create a new law and amend the Colleges Collective Bargaining Act, 2008. Its stated goal is independent evaluation and public reporting on privatizations and public-private partnerships (P3s); that is a goal, not a guaranteed result.
- Public-sector entities would have to assess and report on qualifying service privatizations worth at least $2 million and P3 major capital projects worth at least $20 million before starting procurement.
- The Financial Accountability Officer (FAO) would review the assessments, allow at least 60 days for public and affected-worker comments, and report publicly. The FAO would also review the procurement process and report on it.
- Entities proceeding with a project would have to publish reports during and after the contract, and submit specified reports to the Auditor General for review and comment.
- Private contractors providing public services or taking part in covered P3s would be subject to access-to-information laws for records relevant to those services or partnerships. Firms convicted of, or pleading guilty to, specified offences would be barred from bidding for 10 years.
- For covered transfers involving college-sector employees, the bill would apply the Labour Relations Act, 1995 successor-rights rules, with “sale” changed to “transfer” and “business” to a broadly defined “undertaking.”
What it means for you#
- Public-sector entities: The rules would apply to many Ontario public bodies, including municipalities, school boards, universities, colleges, hospitals, Hydro One and Ontario Power Generation. For a qualifying privatization, an entity must calculate its own service costs, assess private delivery, and prepare a value-for-money audit and business case. For a qualifying P3, it must prepare a public-sector comparator and assess full life-cycle costs, yearly government obligations, risk transfer, borrowing costs and local economic impact.
- The public and affected workers: The FAO must allow at least 60 days for comments on its up-front review. If the entity still proceeds after the required reviews, it must offer a further “reasonable opportunity” to comment. The bill does not require every suggestion to be adopted.
- People seeking records: A covered private contractor would be treated as an institution under Ontario’s access-to-information laws, but requests could cover only records relevant to its public services or P3.
- Private bidders and contractors: A firm convicted of, or pleading guilty to, one of the listed offences would be ineligible to bid on a covered project for 10 years. The list includes fraud, bid-rigging, money laundering and bribery.
- College-sector workers and employers: The amendment would extend successor-rights rules to transfers of an undertaking involving employees covered by the Colleges Collective Bargaining Act. “Undertaking” includes all or part of a business, enterprise, institution, program, project or work. The bill does not itself set out the full effect of those rights.
- Taxpayers and service users: The bill sets out assessment, review and reporting requirements; it does not itself privatize a service, require a P3, or promise savings or better services.
Money#
No cost estimate is in the supplied material. No publicly available information.
- Public bodies, the FAO and the Auditor General would have required assessment, review and reporting work; the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- The bill sets no new tax, fee or fine and does not appropriate a specific amount of money.
- Public-sector comparisons for P3s would have to disclose specified costs, including annual government obligations and the cost of public and private credit.
What is unclear#
- Regulations are allowed to set details, but none are included in the supplied material. This leaves some required calculations, report details and other rules unsettled here.
- The bill does not specify how much time the “reasonable opportunity” for public comment must allow, or how the FAO must handle comments.
- It permits withholding information that could jeopardize competitive value for money, but does not explain how that test would be applied in each case.
- The bill says procurement laws, agreements, policies and procedures still apply, but the supplied material does not explain how they would interact with the new reviews.
- The parent Acts are not supplied, so I could not verify how the proposed changes compare with current law or confirm the full effect of applying the labour successor-rights rules.
- No publicly available information on the bill’s passage or implementation. If enacted, Schedule 1 would start 180 days after Royal Assent; Schedule 2 would start on Royal Assent.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make public bodies compare private delivery or a P3 with public-sector options before committing to procurement.
- Requiring cost, risk and value-for-money analysis could make the reasons for a decision more visible to the public and legislators.
- FAO review, Auditor General comments and recurring reports could help identify whether contractors meet agreed prices, timelines and service standards.
- Applying access-to-information rules to relevant contractor records could make some information available even when a private firm delivers a public service.
Case against#
- One concern is that the assessments, reviews, consultations and repeated reports could add cost and time to covered procurements; the bill provides no estimate of either.
- The bill requires substantial disclosure but allows some information to be withheld for procurement reasons. It is unclear how much the public would see before a contract is awarded.
- The bill does not explain how the new reporting and review duties would fit with existing procurement rules and oversight.
- The 10-year bidding bar is broad in duration, and the bill does not explain how it would apply in every case involving firms, related corporations or offences outside Canada.