Bill relaxes work rules and childcare limits

Summary#

Bill 66, the Restoring Ontario’s Competitiveness Act, 2019, amends and repeals parts of 11 existing Ontario Acts; it does not create one new public program. Its stated goal is to restore Ontario’s competitiveness. The changes affect areas including child care, employment rules, construction-sector bargaining, farming, and long-term care.

  • Farming businesses above an income threshold set by regulation must register and pay a prescribed amount to an accredited farm organization. The Minister may delegate specified administration of the law to an eligible not-for-profit corporation.
  • The bill raises some limits on the number of children under two in home child care and lowers the minimum age for certain authorized recreation programs from six to four.
  • It removes the Director’s approval for certain agreements on work hours and overtime averaging. It also changes construction-sector bargaining rules for named public entities, unless an eligible entity opts out.
  • It changes long-term-care licensing and public consultation rules, removes a restriction on which pension plans may convert to jointly sponsored plans, and allows loan guarantees for loans to entities that lend directly to farmers.
  • It repeals the Pawnbrokers Act, the Wireless Services Agreements Act, 2013, and, on December 31, 2021, the Toxics Reduction Act, 2009. It also removes upholstered or stuffed articles from the Technical Standards and Safety Act’s coverage and allows approved alternate rules in areas covered by that Act.

What it means for you#

  • Farm businesses and farm organizations: A farming business with annual gross income at or above an amount set by regulation must register and pay the prescribed amount through the Ministry to an accredited farm organization. Payment does not make the business a member. A person may apply to the organization for a refund within the prescribed time, subject to the bill’s conditions. The Ministry may charge organizations a fee for collecting and forwarding payments.
  • Agricultural workers: Ornamental horticulture workers come under the Agricultural Employees Protection Act, except municipal employees and people employed in silviculture. Existing bargaining arrangements under the Labour Relations Act for affected unionized workers are preserved.
  • Families and child-care providers: The bill increases the permitted number of children under two in some home-care groups: from two to three with one provider, from four to six with two providers, and from two to three in unlicensed care. It lowers the minimum age for authorized recreation and skill-building programs from six to four. It also changes rules for certain in-home services and school-board third-party programs.
  • Workers and employers: Employees and employers may agree to work beyond the usual 48-hour weekly limit, up to the number in their agreement, without the Director’s approval. Overtime hours may be averaged under an agreement over periods of up to four weeks. Agreements need start and end dates; for employees without a union, they cannot last more than two years. Employers no longer have to post the employment-standards poster at work; the Director must publish it.
  • Construction workers at named public entities: Municipalities and other listed entities—including hospitals, school boards, colleges and some universities—are deemed non-construction employers. For affected construction workers, the union stops representing them and the relevant collective agreement stops applying to construction work, unless the entity made a timely opt-out election. The bill allows an application to redefine a bargaining unit that also includes non-construction workers.
  • Long-term-care homes and residents: The Director may decide how public consultations on specified licensing matters are conducted and may decide a consultation is not warranted, subject to the bill’s rules. The Director may issue a temporary emergency licence for up to one year, without renewal, to accommodate people affected by an emergency.
  • Other affected groups: The bill permits loan guarantees for loans to entities that lend directly to farmers; it does not itself guarantee any particular loan. It removes the stated limit on which single-employer pension plans may convert to jointly sponsored plans, but does not convert a plan. For vehicles registered under the International Registration Plan, an electronic permit may meet the permit requirement if it meets Ministry requirements.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s total public cost.

  • The bill allows prescribed payments from some farm businesses and allows the Ministry to charge accredited farm organizations an administration fee. The amounts are not set in the bill.
  • The bill expands the kinds of loans that may be guaranteed, creating possible public financial exposure; it gives no estimate of guarantees or losses.
  • A Farm Registration Administrator’s financial terms must be set in an agreement with the Minister, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • Regulations must set the farm-income threshold, registration details, payment amounts, and related fees. The bill does not specify them.
  • The bill does not set out the terms or estimated cost of any loan guarantees.
  • It does not say how many farm-administrator staff would be needed or how much the arrangement would cost.
  • The bill changes child-care limits and program rules, but the supplied material does not explain how those changes would affect availability, fees, or care.
  • Some provisions take effect on dates set by proclamation or other commencement rules. The supplied material does not give all of those dates.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce or change regulatory requirements in several areas, rather than create a single new program.
  • Allowing larger groups of very young children in some home-care settings may let providers care for more children within the rules.
  • Removing the Director’s approval step for certain work-hour agreements may make those agreements simpler to arrange.
  • Allowing a farm-administration corporation to take on specified work could give the Ministry another way to administer the registration system.

Case against#

  • Larger groups of children under two may raise concerns about the amount of care and supervision available to each child.
  • Removing approval for extended-hours and overtime-averaging agreements shifts more weight to agreements between employers and employees.
  • The construction rules end some unions’ representation and stop some collective agreements from applying to construction work. The bill does not explain how affected workers will be represented afterward.
  • The Director may decide public consultation is unwarranted for long-term-care licensing matters, and the bill leaves the circumstances to a policy or decision.
  • The bill authorizes broader loan guarantees and delegation of farm-law administration without giving cost estimates.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2019040201

    Passed108 members voted

    Motion for closure on Third Reading of Bill 66

    FOR · 68AGAINST · 40

    68For

    • PC68

    40Against

    • NDP34
    • Liberal4
    • Green1
    • Independent1
  2. Division No. 2019040202

    Passed108 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 66

    FOR · 68AGAINST · 40

    68For

    • PC68

    40Against

    • NDP34
    • Liberal4
    • Green1
    • Independent1
  3. Division No. 2019030601

    Passed96 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 66

    FOR · 64AGAINST · 32

    64For

    • PC64

    32Against

    • NDP28
    • Liberal4
  4. Division No. 2019030502

    Passed103 members voted

    Motion for allocation of time on Bill 66, An Act to restore Ontario’s competitiveness by amending or repealing certain Acts.

    FOR · 61AGAINST · 42

    61For

    • PC61

    42Against

    • NDP36
    • Liberal5
    • Green1