Right to repair electronics bill proposed

Summary#

Bill 72, the Consumer Protection Amendment Act (Right to Repair Electronic Products), 2019, would amend Ontario’s Consumer Protection Act, 2002. Its stated goal is to give consumers and repair businesses access to what they need to repair electronic products.

  • A brand holder (the business whose brand appears on a product) would have to provide, on request, the latest documents, replacement parts, software and other tools it uses or provides to others for diagnosing, maintaining or repairing its branded products.
  • The duty would also cover tools to reset an electronic security function disabled during diagnosis, maintenance or repair.
  • Documents would be free unless paper copies are requested. The brand holder could charge for paper copies, but not more than a reasonable estimate of their cost.
  • The brand holder could charge for parts, software and other tools, but could not price them differently for consumers or repair businesses than for any other person. If it sells repair services, its net profit percentage on those items could not exceed a reasonable estimate of its net profit percentage on those services.
  • The proposed rules would start one year after Royal Assent. The bill does not itself set a calendar start date.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: You could request repair materials for a branded electronic product. This would not make documents free in paper form, or make parts, software and tools free.
  • Consumer electronics repair businesses: You could request the same materials for products covered by the bill. It does not require brand holders to provide materials they do not use or provide to others.
  • Brand holders: You would have to provide covered materials when requested and follow the bill’s limits on charges. The text does not set a response deadline.
  • Current law: The bill amends Ontario’s Consumer Protection Act, but the Act itself was not supplied. I could not verify what repair-related rights or rules already exist.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require brand holders to provide materials, but gives no estimate of their costs or staffing needs.
  • Brand holders could charge for parts, software, tools and requested paper copies, subject to the bill’s limits.
  • No government spending, fee paid to government, or funding program is specified.

What is unclear#

  • No publicly available information is supplied about the bill’s status or whether it received Royal Assent.
  • The bill does not set a process for requests, a response time, or a way to appeal a refusal or delay.
  • It does not explain how the limits based on a “reasonable estimate” would be set or enforced.
  • The text does not say whether or how these rules interact with repair protections already in the Consumer Protection Act.
  • It does not specify a remedy or enforcement process for a brand holder that fails to comply.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that repair information and tools can be hard to obtain when a brand holder controls them.
  • Providing those materials could give consumers and repair businesses more options to diagnose and repair covered products.
  • Allowing charges, while limiting them, could let brand holders recover costs without permitting different prices for consumers or repair businesses.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill sets no deadline or request process, so access could be delayed or difficult to enforce.
  • The bill does not require brand holders to provide materials they do not use or provide to others. The practical range of materials available could therefore vary.
  • The pricing limits rely on “reasonable” estimates, but the bill does not explain how those estimates would be checked.
  • The bill creates a duty but does not specify its enforcement process or remedies for non-compliance.