Summary#
Bill 187, the Right to Repair Consumer Electronic Products, Household Appliances, Wheelchairs, Motor Vehicles and Farming Heavy Equipment Act, 2024, would amend Ontario’s Consumer Protection Act, 2023. Its stated goal is to give consumers and repair businesses access to materials needed to repair covered products; that goal is not a guaranteed result. If enacted, it would start on a day set by proclamation.
- At a consumer’s or eligible repair business’s request, manufacturers must provide the most recent repair manual, replacement parts, software and tools they use or provide to others for diagnosing, maintaining or repairing covered products, or for resetting certain electronic security functions.
- For electronic products, household appliances and wheelchairs, the request may come from a consumer or repair business. For motor vehicles and farming heavy equipment, it may come from a consumer or a repair business serving consumers.
- Manufacturers must provide access to repair manuals at no charge. They may charge a reasonable amount for a printed manual.
- Manufacturers may charge for parts, software and tools, but the bill requires the fee to meet conditions on charging different people and on the manufacturer’s profit percentage if it provides repair services.
What it means for you#
- Consumers: You could request the listed repair materials for products covered by the bill. You would not have to use them or repair the product yourself. The bill does not require repairs to be free.
- Repair businesses: Eligible businesses could request the listed materials for covered products used by consumers. The bill does not set up an application or approval process beyond making a request.
- Manufacturers: They would have to provide the materials within a “reasonable time.” This is a duty, not an option, but the bill does not set a specific number of days.
- Other people and organizations: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or who owns a product. It does not create a new agency or require manufacturers to provide repair services.
Money#
No publicly available information on estimated public or private costs is included in the supplied materials.
- Manufacturers could charge for replacement parts, software and tools, subject to the bill’s fee conditions.
- A printed repair manual could be charged at no more than a reasonable estimate of printing costs; access to the manual must be free.
- The bill does not state what it would cost manufacturers to provide the materials or what the effects on repair prices would be.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “reasonable time,” “fair cost,” or “reasonable estimate” of costs or profit.
- If a manufacturer does not provide repair services, the bill gives no repair-service profit percentage to use as a comparison for its parts, software and tools fees.
- The bill does not set out complaint, appeal or enforcement procedures in the new sections. The Consumer Protection Act, 2023 was not supplied, so I could not verify what enforcement rules already exist or how these new duties would fit with current law.
- The bill does not specify how requests must be made or how often manufacturers must update the materials.
- The bill does not give a start date; that would be set by proclamation.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address situations where consumers and repair businesses lack access to materials that manufacturers use or provide to others.
- Requiring manufacturers to provide those materials could give consumers and repair businesses more options for carrying out repairs.
- Free access to repair manuals and limits on fees for other materials could make some repair information and supplies more accessible. The bill does not guarantee lower repair costs.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill sets no specific deadline beyond “within a reasonable time,” so how quickly a manufacturer must respond is unclear.
- The fee rules use terms such as “fair cost” and “reasonable” without defining them, which could leave disputes about prices unresolved in these sections.
- The bill requires manufacturers to provide a broad set of materials, but the supplied text does not estimate the cost or explain how compliance would be checked.
- The bill does not explain how its new duties would interact with existing law or provide a specific process for resolving a consumer’s or repair business’s complaint.