Summary#
Bill 82, the Single-Use Plastics Ban Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Resource Recovery and Circular Economy Act, 2016. Its stated goal is to eliminate the distribution and supply of single-use plastics in Ontario by 2025; that goal is not a guarantee that elimination will happen.
- Within one year after Royal Assent, the Minister must amend and publish the province’s Strategy with a plan setting measurable targets and timelines for reducing and eventually eliminating single-use plastics.
- The plan must require immediate elimination of plastic straws and drink stirrers, expanded polystyrene foam food and beverage containers, plastic bags, items made from oxo-degradable or oxo-fragmentable plastics, disposable coffee cups, single-use plastic water bottles, and other plastics the Minister believes should be eliminated immediately.
- The plan may include transitional arrangements. The bill does not itself set product-by-product compliance dates or a process for businesses to follow.
- The Minister must publish a progress report at least once a year until the Minister believes distribution and supply have been eliminated. The report must describe actions taken and progress measured against measures established under the Act.
What it means for you#
- Ontario government: The Minister must prepare and publish the plan within one year of Royal Assent, then publish annual progress reports until the Minister believes distribution and supply have ended.
- Businesses supplying the named products: The plan must require their immediate elimination, but this bill does not itself set out how or when each business must comply. The practical effect depends on the plan and any transitional arrangements.
- Consumers: The bill does not itself immediately prohibit consumers from possessing or using these products. It directs the Minister to create a plan focused on their distribution and supply.
- General public: The reports would make actions and measured progress public. The bill does not directly change taxes, fees, or benefits.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s costs.
- The Minister must prepare the plan and annual reports, but the bill gives no estimate of the staff or other resources needed.
- The bill does not set out a new fee, fine, appropriation, or funding source.
What is unclear#
- The supplied materials do not include the Resource Recovery and Circular Economy Act, 2016, so I could not verify what the Act’s existing Strategy, performance measures, or other requirements already provide.
- “Single-use plastics” covers prescribed products and excludes anything prescribed as excluded. The bill does not identify all products that would fall within those rules.
- The bill does not set out enforcement powers, penalties, exemptions, or a compliance process for businesses.
- The Minister may add other plastics to the immediate-elimination list, but the bill gives no criteria for that decision.
- The bill does not say how progress will be judged beyond referring to performance measures established under the Act, or what evidence would support the Minister’s view that elimination has been achieved.
Case for#
- A plan with measurable targets and timelines could make the intended reduction more specific than a general goal.
- Requiring immediate elimination of named product types gives the plan a clear starting list, while allowing the Minister to add other types.
- Annual public reports could let people track what the government has done and what progress it reports.
Case against#
- The bill leaves important details to the future plan and to rules defining which products count, so businesses and the public cannot tell from this bill alone exactly what would be covered or when.
- The bill requires a plan to require immediate elimination, but does not itself set compliance dates, enforcement rules, or penalties.
- The Minister decides when to stop reporting by forming an opinion that distribution and supply have been eliminated; the bill does not specify an independent test for that conclusion.
- Preparing the plan and reports will require government work, but the bill provides no cost estimate or dedicated funding.