Summary#
Bill 57, the Paris Galt Moraine Conservation Act, 2021, would create a new Act and amend five existing Acts. It would let the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing establish a conservation plan for a land area designated by regulation; the bill’s stated goal is to protect the area’s ecological and hydrological functions.
- The Minister may establish the Plan, and the Lieutenant Governor in Council may designate the area it covers. The bill does not itself set out a map or establish the Plan.
- Once a Plan applies, specified planning decisions must conform to it. The Plan would prevail over conflicting official plans, zoning by-laws and provincial policy statements under the Planning Act.
- Municipalities and municipal planning authorities would have to make required official plan amendments; municipalities with jurisdiction would have to amend zoning by-laws. The Minister could step in to amend them if a municipality does not resolve a conflict.
- The Plan may prohibit or restrict land and building uses and set policies for land, resource and water protection. The bill also creates offences, with daily fines of up to $25,000 for individuals and $50,000 for corporations on a first conviction, and higher maximums for later convictions.
- The bill protects certain lawful existing uses, buildings, permits and applications from being blocked by the Act or Plan, subject to stated conditions.
What it means for you#
- Municipalities and planning authorities: If the Plan is established and filed, they would have 18 months to make required planning changes. If a municipality fails to address a conflict, the Minister may amend its official plan or zoning by-law; that order would be final and not appealable.
- People and businesses seeking land-use approvals: Decisions under the Planning Act and Condominium Act, 1998, among others, would have to conform to the Plan. What uses are allowed would depend on the Plan’s eventual contents. The bill does not itself set up an application or review process for every property.
- Owners and operators with existing uses or projects: Some lawful uses and previously authorized or in-progress projects are protected. For example, certain existing uses may continue, and some expansions are allowed if conditions are met. An existing mineral aggregate operation or wayside pit in a natural core area could not expand beyond its licensed or permitted boundary.
- First Nations: The Minister must consult First Nations whose treaty lands, territory or Aboriginal rights are affected or potentially affected during a 10-year Plan review. The bill does not specify a consultation process for first establishing the Plan.
- People and corporations: Breaching a Plan prohibition or restriction could lead to a daily fine. A court could also order steps to reduce harm or stop similar conduct.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated cost.
- The Minister must arrange a Plan review every 10 years and consult during that review; municipalities would also have to prepare planning amendments. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- The Minister or a municipality may make agreements that share the costs of implementing Plan features.
- The Minister may set fees for applications to amend the Plan. The bill does not set fee amounts.
- The bill does not appropriate a specific amount of money.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not identify the area’s boundaries or give the Plan’s land-use rules. Those would depend on later regulations.
- It is unclear which municipalities or public bodies would be prescribed and what the Plan would require of them.
- The bill does not set out the process, timing or public-participation rules for first establishing the Plan. It does require public participation during later 10-year reviews.
- The supplied material does not include the amended Acts themselves, so their current wording and the full effect of the related amendments cannot be verified.
- The bill says the Act would be deemed to have come into force on November 24, 2021, if enacted. The supplied material does not establish whether it became law.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to protect water and ecological functions across a designated area, rather than leave those goals to separate local planning decisions.
- Requiring planning decisions to conform to one Plan could make its protections apply across municipal boundaries.
- The Plan could restrict land uses and below-water-table aggregate extraction, while allowing some stricter local rules to remain.
- Regular reviews and consultation with affected public bodies, municipalities, the public and affected First Nations could allow the Plan to be reconsidered over time.
Case against#
- The bill leaves the area’s boundaries and the Plan’s actual rules to later government decisions, so its practical reach is not clear from the bill.
- The Minister would have broad power to approve or change municipal planning amendments, and some decisions would be final with no appeal.
- The bill gives no detailed process for creating the initial Plan or for involving affected First Nations at that stage.
- Required reviews, municipal amendments and enforcement could have costs, but the bill provides no estimates or staffing details.
- The objectives include restricting below-water-table aggregate extraction, but the bill does not itself specify the restriction or define how it would apply.