Summary#
Bill 10 would amend Ontario’s Municipal Act, 2001 and City of Toronto Act, 2006. The bill text gives its short title as the Stopping Harassment and Abuse by Local Leaders Act, 2021; the supplied title line labels it 2022. Its stated goal is to address workplace violence and harassment policies in codes of conduct for councillors and local board members.
- Municipal and local board codes of conduct must require members to comply with the workplace violence or harassment policies that the municipality or board has established under the Occupational Health and Safety Act.
- If an Integrity Commissioner reports that a member’s failure to follow those policies breached the code, the municipality or local board may direct the Commissioner to seek a court decision.
- Once directed, the Commissioner must apply to a Superior Court judge. If the judge finds a breach, the judge may declare the member’s seat vacant; this is not automatic.
- No such application may be made from nomination day through voting day in a regular municipal election.
- The bill would start on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not establish whether it became law.
What it means for you#
- Councillors and local board members: Their code of conduct would have to require them to follow the relevant workplace violence or harassment policies.
- Municipalities and local boards: They may direct their Integrity Commissioner to apply to court after the Commissioner reports an opinion that a member breached the code by failing to follow those policies.
- Integrity Commissioners: If directed, they must apply to a judge for a determination.
- Members facing an application: A judge—not the Commissioner or council alone—would decide whether there was a breach. A judge could declare the seat vacant. The application cannot be made during the stated regular-election period.
- The public: The bill does not directly create a new public service or change who can vote or run for office.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill would require an Integrity Commissioner to make a court application if directed, but gives no estimate of the staffing or court costs.
- The bill does not set out a new tax, fee, fine, or appropriation.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the two parent Acts, so I could not verify the current code-of-conduct rules, existing penalties, or how these provisions would interact with current law.
- The bill does not set out how the Commissioner’s inquiry works, how quickly it must happen, or what evidence or decision standard applies. Other rules may address these points, but they are not supplied.
- The bill does not define the workplace violence or harassment policies or explain how a court application would interact with other existing ways to address a policy breach.
- The bill does not give a start date beyond Royal Assent, and the supplied material does not show its legislative status.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make workplace violence and harassment policies part of elected officials’ formal conduct rules.
- A possible argument for the court step is that a judge would decide whether a breach occurred and whether a seat should be vacated.
- The measure is limited: a municipality or local board may direct an application, and a judge may—not must—vacate the seat.
- The election-period restriction avoids making these applications during the specified part of a regular election.
Case against#
- A possible trade-off is that a breach of a workplace policy could lead to loss of an elected seat, even though the judge’s decision to vacate it is discretionary.
- The bill lets a municipality or local board decide whether to direct an application, but the supplied text does not explain how that decision is made or what safeguards govern it.
- The bill does not spell out the inquiry and court process. Without those details, it is hard to assess how consistent or timely cases would be.
- The bill requires the Commissioner to apply once directed, but gives no estimate of the resulting staff or court costs.