Tax-Free Psychotherapy Services Bill Advances

Summary#

Bill 120, the Making Psychotherapy Services Tax-Free Act, 2022, would create a new Act; it does not amend the Psychotherapy Act, 2007. It would require the Minister of Health to take all necessary steps to make the tax treatment of specified psychotherapy services the same as that of services provided by other practitioners. The bill’s stated goal is to improve access to mental health support.

  • The duty covers services in Ontario provided by psychotherapists, registered psychotherapists and registered mental health therapists, as those terms are used in the Psychotherapy Act, 2007.
  • The minister may need to introduce legislation to achieve equal tax treatment, but the bill does not specify what tax change would be made.
  • The bill does not itself set a tax exemption or rate, or say that the services will have no tax. “Tax-free” is the short title; the operative rule is equal treatment with other practitioners.
  • The Act would take effect on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Minister of Health: Would have a legal duty to take all necessary steps to achieve the stated equal tax treatment. The bill does not set a deadline or spell out those steps.
  • People receiving the named practitioners’ services: The bill does not itself specify a change to the tax charged on a service or to its price. Any effect would depend on the steps taken to meet the minister’s duty.
  • Specified practitioners: Their services would be covered by the duty to align tax treatment. The bill does not create a new licensing or service-approval process.
  • Other practitioners: Their services are the comparison point, but the bill does not identify which practitioners or tax treatment it means.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Minister of Health to take steps, which could include introducing legislation, but gives no estimate of staffing or other public costs.
  • It does not specify a tax exemption, rate, refund, or amount of tax revenue that might change.

What is unclear#

  • Which taxes and which “other practitioners” are meant by the comparison.
  • Whether equal treatment would mean exempting these services from a tax, applying a tax, or making some other change.
  • What steps the minister must take, and when they must be completed.
  • Whether any later legislation, rules or other measures would be needed to put a tax change into effect.
  • The bill refers to terms in the Psychotherapy Act, 2007, but that Act was not supplied, so the current legal meaning of those terms and the existing tax treatment could not be verified against it.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address unequal tax treatment of psychotherapy services provided by the named practitioners.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that aligning tax treatment could make the rules more consistent across practitioners providing comparable services.
  • The bill’s preamble says psychotherapy can help people facing a range of physical and mental health challenges; improving access is its stated aim.

Case against#

  • The bill does not say what tax treatment it seeks to match, so it is unclear what result the minister must deliver.
  • It gives the minister a broad duty to take “all necessary steps” without a deadline or a defined process.
  • The bill does not establish that equal tax treatment would lower the price people pay or increase access to services.
  • The costs to government and any effect on tax revenue are not estimated.