Summary#
Bill 61, the Making Psychotherapy Services Tax-Free Act, 2023, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend the Psychotherapy Act, 2007. Its stated goal is to make psychotherapy more accessible by reducing financial barriers, but the bill itself does not set a specific tax rate or exemption.
- The Minister of Health would have to take all necessary steps to give psychotherapy services provided in Ontario by the named practitioners the same tax treatment as those services provided by other practitioners.
- Those steps may include introducing more legislation if needed. The bill does not itself change tax rules for providers or clients.
- The named practitioners are psychotherapists, registered psychotherapists and registered mental health therapists within the meaning of the Psychotherapy Act, 2007.
- The bill’s preamble discusses fuller public funding for mental health services as an eventual goal, but the bill does not require public funding of psychotherapy.
What it means for you#
- People seeking psychotherapy: The bill does not itself guarantee that sessions will become tax-free, cheaper or publicly funded. Any change would depend on the tax treatment chosen and steps taken by the minister.
- Named practitioners: The minister would have a legal duty to take steps toward equal tax treatment for their services. The bill does not set application rules or require practitioners to change how they provide or charge for services.
- Other practitioners: The bill uses their services as the comparison point, but does not identify which practitioners or specify the tax treatment to match.
Money#
No cost or tax-revenue estimate is available in the supplied material.
- The bill requires action by the Minister of Health, but gives no staffing or administrative cost estimate.
- If the eventual change reduces tax collected, it could affect public revenue; the amount and even the precise tax change are not specified.
- The bill does not set a fee, fine, benefit, or funding amount.
What is unclear#
- Which tax or taxes are covered, and whether “the same tax treatment” means tax-free treatment.
- Which “other practitioners” provide the comparison, and what tax treatment their services receive.
- What steps the minister must take, and by when. The bill sets no deadline, reporting requirement or review process.
- Whether further legislation would be needed, and what it would say.
- How the proposed tax change would interact with existing tax rules or public health coverage.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to reduce financial barriers to psychotherapy and treat services by the named practitioners on an equal tax basis with comparable services.
- A possible argument for the bill is that equal tax treatment could remove a tax disadvantage for people seeking services from those practitioners.
- The minister’s duty to take necessary steps means the issue would require government action, rather than being only an expression of support.
Case against#
- The bill does not specify the tax change. Its title suggests tax-free services, but the legal text only requires equal treatment with an unnamed group.
- The minister’s duty has no deadline or stated measure of completion, so the bill does not ensure when—or exactly how—treatment would change.
- The bill does not require lower client prices or public funding. Equal tax treatment would not, by itself, guarantee either result.
- Any effect on tax revenue and the cost of carrying out the required steps are unknown.