Summary#
Bill 21, the Taxation Amendment Act (Travel Ontario Tax Credit), 2021, would amend Ontario’s Taxation Act, 2007. Its stated goal is to encourage tourism within Ontario by allowing a non-refundable tax credit of up to $1,000 for eligible individuals who were Ontario residents at the end of a taxation year ending after December 31, 2019.
- The credit would reduce tax otherwise payable; it would not be a payment to a person.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council could make rules for administering the credit, including rules about receipts and other information people may have to provide.
- The bill would start on Royal Assent. It does not set out a formula for calculating the credit or specify qualifying travel expenses.
What it means for you#
- Ontario residents: If you meet the bill’s eligibility rules, you could deduct up to $1,000 from tax otherwise payable for a qualifying taxation year. Because the credit is non-refundable, it cannot reduce your tax below zero or provide cash beyond the tax you owe.
- People who travelled in Ontario: The explanatory note describes the credit as being for travel in Ontario for tourism. The bill itself does not say which travel or expenses qualify. Rules could also require receipts or other information.
- Tourism businesses: The bill does not require businesses to do anything or create a direct payment to them. More tourism is the stated goal, not a guaranteed result.
Money#
No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- The credit could reduce Ontario tax revenue, but the material gives no estimate of how many people might claim it or the total cost.
- The bill sets a maximum credit of $1,000 per eligible individual, but does not explain how the credit amount would be calculated.
- The bill allows rules that may require receipts or other information. It provides no estimate of related administration or compliance costs.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “eligible person” or state which travel costs qualify. The explanatory note refers to tourism travel in Ontario, but does not give further rules.
- It is unclear how the credit amount would be calculated, how a person would claim it, or what deadlines and review or appeal steps would apply.
- The bill could apply to taxation years ending after December 31, 2019, including years before Royal Assent. How claims for those years would work is not stated.
- The bill does not give a cost estimate or say how the credit would interact with other tax credits.
- The Taxation Act, 2007 was not supplied, so existing definitions, tax rules and any overlap with current provisions could not be checked.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to encourage tourism within Ontario by reducing the tax bill of eligible residents who make qualifying trips.
- A possible argument for the approach is that a tax credit gives residents a direct financial incentive to spend on tourism in Ontario.
- Setting a maximum credit of $1,000 limits the amount any one eligible individual could deduct under this provision.
Case against#
- The bill leaves key eligibility and expense rules to future regulations, so people cannot tell from the bill what travel would qualify or how much they could claim.
- Because the credit is non-refundable, people who owe little or no tax may receive little or no benefit, even if they have qualifying expenses.
- The bill gives no cost estimate, and its coverage of tax years ending after 2019 could affect earlier years once it comes into force.
- The material does not show whether the credit would lead to more tourism or how any increase would be measured.