Summary#
Bill 134, the Budget Measures Act (Housing Price Stability and Ontario Seniors' Public Transit Tax Credit), 2017, amends Ontario’s Land Transfer Tax Act and Taxation Act, 2007. It was enacted as Chapter 17 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2017. The title identifies housing price stability as a goal; the bill does not guarantee that result.
- It adds a 15% tax to certain land transfers in the specified region when designated land is conveyed to a foreign entity or taxable trustee.
- It makes the person tendering the conveyance for registration responsible for paying that tax. Some exemptions and rebates are available under conditions set out in the law or to be prescribed.
- It creates a refundable Ontario seniors’ public transit tax credit: generally 15% of eligible transit costs, up to $225 for the 2017 tax year and $450 for later years.
- It requires certain transferees to provide additional information if a statement, affidavit or return is required under the Land Transfer Tax Act. A false or misleading statement for determining the additional tax can lead to a fine of up to $10,000.
What it means for you#
- People and entities buying designated land: If the conveyance is to a foreign entity or taxable trustee and the land is in the specified region, the person tendering it for registration must pay the additional tax. “Designated land” includes land with one to six single-family residences; regulations may add other land. The Greater Golden Horseshoe is included, subject to possible prescribed exclusions, and regulations may add other areas.
- Some buyers and trusts: The law provides an exemption for qualifying purchase agreements made by April 20, 2017, and qualifying assignments made by that date. It also allows prescribed exemptions and rebates tied to requirements such as residency, citizenship, education or employment. Some types of trusts are excluded from the definition of taxable trustee.
- People acquiring a beneficial interest: If several people acquire, or increase, a beneficial interest in the land, they can be jointly and severally liable for the additional tax (each can be held responsible for the full amount).
- Ontario seniors: To qualify, you generally must be an Ontario resident at the end of the tax year and at least 65 at the end of the previous tax year. Eligible costs include qualifying transit passes, electronic payment cards, single-use tickets and specialized transportation. The 2017 credit covers eligible use from July 1 to December 31; later years cover the year.
- Transit organizations: The credit does not require transit organizations to introduce a new fare or service. Some passes, cards and specialized-transport payments qualify only if they meet the law’s conditions, including receipt or usage records where specified.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- The additional land-transfer tax is 15% of the conveyance’s value of consideration, unless an alternate rate is prescribed. The person tendering the conveyance pays it.
- The refundable transit credit is limited to 15% of eligible costs after relevant reimbursements or assistance, subject to the annual cap.
- The bill gives the Minister power to prescribe some rules, exemptions and an alternate tax rate, but the material provides no estimate of the resulting public revenue, credit cost, staffing or administration costs.
What is unclear#
- The material does not give all regulations that would define added or excluded land, alternate tax rates, exemption requirements or rebate requirements.
- It does not set out an application process, timelines or review steps for rebates.
- The supplied material does not include the parent Acts in full, so I could not verify how these amendments interact with all existing rules.
- The bill does not show how much tax would be collected or how much the transit credit would cost.
Case for#
- The land tax could be seen as a way to discourage or limit certain foreign-entity purchases of designated residential land in specified areas. Whether it affects housing prices is not guaranteed by the bill.
- The refundable credit could help eligible seniors pay some public transit costs, including costs for specialized transportation.
- The tax includes exemptions and rebates, which can reduce the tax for some qualifying buyers.
Case against#
- One concern is that the tax applies at a high rate—15%—and the bill leaves important details about covered land and exemptions to regulations.
- Joint and several liability means one person with a beneficial interest could be responsible for the full additional tax, not just their share.
- The bill does not establish the amount of public revenue or credit cost, or explain the practical process for rebates.
- The transit credit is capped and limited by age, residency and eligible-cost rules, so it will not cover all seniors or all transit spending.