Province Takes Control of Two Roads

Summary#

Bill 26, the Uploading Highways 174 and 17 Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act. Its stated goal is to place Ottawa Road 174 and County Road 17 under provincial jurisdiction and control.

  • The roads would cease to be vested in any municipality and would no longer be part of a municipal road system.
  • The Ministry of Transportation would have jurisdiction and control of the roads.
  • Municipal agreements and permits related to the roads would continue as if the Minister had made or granted them. Municipal rights, privileges and benefits under those agreements would pass to the provincial Crown, which would also be bound by them.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council could not direct a transfer of these roads under the Act’s section 29 transfer power.
  • The Act would start on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Municipalities: They would no longer hold the roads or have them in their road systems. Their rights, privileges and benefits under related agreements would pass to the provincial Crown.
  • People and businesses with a permit or agreement related to the roads: The bill says it would remain in force as if granted or made by the Minister. It does not set out a new application or review process.
  • Road users: The bill changes who has legal jurisdiction and control. It does not directly change traffic rules, fees or road-user eligibility.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of the transfer.

  • The bill gives no cost estimate and does not set out an appropriation, fee or staffing requirement.
  • The text does not explain how road-related costs would be divided between the province and municipalities.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so the current legal arrangements and the existing section 29 transfer process could not be verified.
  • The bill does not spell out what day-to-day responsibilities or services follow from the Ministry’s jurisdiction and control.
  • It does not describe how existing agreements and permits would be administered, or how disputes about them would be handled.
  • It does not give a cost, funding plan or transition details.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that one level of government would have jurisdiction and control of both roads, rather than the roads remaining vested in municipalities.
  • Keeping existing agreements and permits in force could avoid ending them just because control changes.
  • Preventing future transfer directions under section 29 could provide certainty about which level of government controls the roads.

Case against#

  • The bill transfers jurisdiction and control without explaining the resulting division of day-to-day duties or how the province will fund them.
  • Municipal rights, privileges and benefits under existing agreements would pass to the provincial Crown, but the bill gives no details about how those arrangements would work in practice.
  • The bill does not set out a transition process or explain how municipalities or people affected by existing permits and agreements would be involved.