Summary#
Bill 39, the Better Municipal Governance Act, 2022, amends the City of Toronto Act, 2006 and the Municipal Act, 2001, and enacts a new law repealing the Duffins Rouge Agricultural Preserve Act, 2005. Its title presents the goal as improving municipal governance. The bill was enacted as Chapter 24 of Ontario’s 2022 statutes, but the schedules take effect on dates set by proclamation; the supplied material does not give those dates.
- Toronto’s mayor, and the heads of council in municipalities covered by the new rule, may propose certain by-laws they believe could advance a prescribed provincial priority and require council to vote on them. More than one third of council members must vote in favour for such a by-law to pass.
- The mayor must provide the proposed by-law and reasons to the clerk and every council member, as required by regulations. The mayor may vote on it.
- The Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing may appoint the heads of council of Niagara, Peel and York for the term of office beginning in 2022. The Minister may also set the appointment’s duration and make regulations about it.
- The new Duffins Rouge law repeals the 2005 Act and changes the legal effect of easements and covenants described in that Act. It also makes certain related legal claims and proceedings unavailable.
What it means for you#
- Residents and municipal councils: In Toronto and municipalities covered by the new by-law rule, the head of council may require a vote on eligible by-laws despite the municipality’s usual procedure rules. This is a power, not a requirement to propose a by-law. It does not apply to every possible by-law: the bill allows exclusions to be prescribed.
- Residents of Niagara, Peel and York: The Minister may appoint the regional head of council for the term beginning in 2022. If the Minister makes an appointment, a head of council appointed by council stops holding that appointment when the ministerial appointment takes effect.
- People and organizations connected to affected Duffins Rouge lands: The legal treatment of the specified easements and covenants changes. Notices registered under the Conservation Land Act for those interests become ineffective when the relevant section takes effect. The law bars compensation for losses arising from the changes and dismisses covered proceedings already underway. It does not bar an application for judicial review.
- Taxpayers: The bill does not directly change taxes, fees, or municipal services.
Money#
No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- The bill gives the Minister appointment and regulation-making powers and requires notice of any appointment.
- Mayors must provide proposed by-laws and reasons to municipal clerks and council members. The material gives no staffing or cost estimate for these duties.
- The bill does not state an appropriation, fee, fine, or compensation payment. For the Duffins Rouge changes, it expressly says affected people are not entitled to compensation.
What is unclear#
- The material does not give the proclamation dates, so it does not establish when each schedule took effect.
- The bill does not define “provincial priority” in the supplied text. Regulations may prescribe priorities, requirements, and exclusions.
- The supplied material does not say which municipalities are covered by the new by-law power beyond Toronto, or provide the regulations governing notice and procedure.
- The bill allows the Minister to appoint regional heads of council, but does not say whether appointments were made or what their duration would be.
- The parent Acts and the full details of the 2005 Duffins Rouge law are not supplied. I could not verify the changes against the complete current law or identify every affected easement and covenant.
Case for#
- The bill gives a head of council a way to bring forward a by-law tied to a provincial priority and ensure council considers and votes on it.
- A lower voting threshold for those by-laws could make it possible to pass one even if it cannot gain the support required under ordinary municipal rules.
- The ministerial appointment power could provide a direct way to choose regional heads of council for the specified term.
- The Duffins Rouge provisions set out the legal effect of the repeal and prevent related claims for compensation, which may reduce uncertainty about disputes covered by the law.
Case against#
- A mayor could require a vote despite council’s usual procedures, and a by-law could pass with support from just over one third of council members. This gives the head of council and a minority of council members greater power over those decisions.
- The bill lets the Minister appoint regional heads of council rather than leaving that choice to council members, and gives the Minister broad regulation-making powers, including power to modify how other municipal laws apply.
- The bill bars many legal claims and compensation related to the Duffins Rouge changes, including claims already in progress. This limits remedies for people who say they suffered a loss, although judicial review remains available.
- Without the regulations and full parent laws, it is hard to tell how broadly the new powers apply or exactly which land interests are affected.