New offence links traffic violations to fatal harm

Summary#

Bill 62, the Fairness for Road Users Act (Contraventions Causing Death or Serious Bodily Harm), 2021, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act by creating a new offence. Its stated goal is to address cases where a traffic-law violation is connected to an accident that causes death or serious bodily harm.

  • A person would commit the offence if, while contravening the Act or its regulations, they cause or contribute to causing an accident that results in death or serious bodily harm.
  • A court would have to impose a fine of at least $2,000 and up to $50,000, or could impose up to two years in prison, or both.
  • A court could also suspend the person’s driver’s licence or permit for up to five years.
  • The bill says it would take effect on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Road users: The new offence would apply only where a person was contravening the Highway Traffic Act or its regulations and caused or contributed to an accident resulting in death or serious bodily harm. It would not cover every accident with those consequences.
  • People convicted: The fine would have a $2,000 minimum. Prison and a licence suspension would not be automatic; the court could impose either or both, within the stated limits.
  • Other traffic offences: The bill adds an offence. It does not say whether or how it would overlap with existing offences. The Highway Traffic Act was not supplied, so the current law and any existing penalties could not be verified.

Money#

The bill sets fines, but the available material gives no estimate of public costs or revenue.

  • A person convicted would face a fine of $2,000 to $50,000, alone or alongside imprisonment.
  • The material does not estimate court, prosecution, or possible imprisonment costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “serious bodily harm.”
  • It does not explain how a court should decide whether a person “contributes to causing” an accident.
  • The text does not state an additional intent or carelessness requirement; how that affects the offence would depend on the law and its interpretation.
  • Without the current Highway Traffic Act, it is unclear how this offence would interact with existing offences and penalties.
  • The bill does not provide details about how the offence would be investigated or prosecuted.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make serious consequences of traffic-law violations subject to a specific offence, rather than relying only on the underlying violation.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that it connects the penalty to both a breach of traffic law and the death or serious bodily harm that follows.
  • The fine, prison term, and possible licence suspension give courts several possible sanctions, with some discretion over which to impose.

Case against#

  • The offence covers a person who causes or contributes to an accident while contravening the Act or regulations, but the bill does not spell out an additional intent or carelessness requirement.
  • “Serious bodily harm” is not defined in the bill, leaving an important boundary unclear.
  • The $2,000 minimum fine would apply to anyone convicted, while the bill does not set out factors for choosing a penalty.
  • The bill does not explain how this offence would fit with existing offences, so possible overlap is unclear.