Summary#
Bill 62, the Protecting Vulnerable Road Users Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act by creating a new offence for certain collisions that cause or contribute to death or serious bodily harm. Its stated goal is to address the legal consequences of harm to vulnerable road users.
- A driver of a motor vehicle other than a motor-assisted bicycle would commit the new offence if they caused or contributed to death or serious bodily harm by breaking one or more listed road rules. The listed people include pedestrians, cyclists, mobility-device users, road workers, and certain emergency responders outside a motor vehicle.
- The bill says the new offence would not be an absolute-liability offence (one where the prosecution does not have to prove fault).
- On conviction, the driver would face the penalty and other consequences for breaking the listed rule, plus a mandatory probation order lasting up to one year. It must require a driving instruction course and 50 to 200 hours of community service, including work related to driving safety.
- The driver’s licence would be suspended during probation. The driver must attend sentencing hearings, and the court must consider relevant victim impact statements.
- A court could extend probation by up to one additional year in some cases where the driver fails to complete the course or service but shows good cause. A conviction for breaching the order could bring a fine of up to $50,000; the court may also suspend a licence or permit for up to two years.
- Most provisions would start six months after Royal Assent. Some amendments would start on a date set by proclamation. The materials do not say whether the bill became law.
What it means for you#
- Drivers: A collision alone would not trigger the new offence. The driver must be convicted of causing or contributing to death or serious bodily harm while contravening a listed rule. The listed rules include rules on matters such as impaired or unlicensed driving, speeding, careless driving, signals, and safe conduct around pedestrians and emergency vehicles.
- Drivers convicted: The court must order probation, a driving course, and safety-related community service. The bill does not say who pays for the course. The licence suspension lasts for the probation period.
- People harmed and their families: The court must consider relevant statements about physical or emotional harm, property damage, economic loss, and the offence’s impact. The court decides how a statement may be presented and which parts are relevant.
- Other road users: The bill would not directly create a new right to compensation or a new collision-reporting service. It creates an offence and sentencing consequences.
- Courts and prosecutors: Proceedings for the new offence, and for the listed-rule offence alleged in connection with it, must begin by laying an information, not by filing a certificate of offence. The bill says a proceeding started by certificate is void.
Money#
The bill requires courses, community service, court proceedings, and licence suspensions, but no cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- The bill does not state how much courses would cost or who would pay for them.
- It requires community service but does not provide a public cost estimate for administering or supervising it.
- A fine of up to $50,000 applies only to a person convicted of breaching the probation order. No estimate of fines or related revenue is provided.
What is unclear#
- “Serious bodily harm” is not defined in the supplied bill text.
- The bill allows regulations to add people to the protected group and set course requirements. The materials do not give those rules.
- The bill does not set details such as the course’s length, how community service is arranged, or how compliance is monitored.
- The Highway Traffic Act was not supplied, so I could not verify how the listed provisions compare with current law or whether they have changed since this bill was introduced.
- The materials do not establish the bill’s status or the dates for any proclamation provisions.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to add consequences when a driver breaks a listed road rule and causes or contributes to death or serious bodily harm.
- A possible argument for the mandatory course and safety-related service is that they connect sentencing with driving education and public safety.
- The bill covers several groups who may be exposed to traffic risks, including road workers and emergency responders outside vehicles.
- Requiring the court to consider victim impact statements gives the sentencing process a way to hear about harm to people affected.
Case against#
- One concern is that the extra consequences would be mandatory on conviction, including licence suspension, even though the court can set the community-service hours only within the 50-to-200-hour range.
- The terms “serious bodily harm” and “causes or contributes” are not explained in the supplied text, leaving important questions about how the offence would apply.
- The bill leaves course requirements and the addition of protected groups to regulations, without setting those details in the bill.
- It is unclear how the course and community service would be arranged, supervised, or paid for.