Summary#
Bill 64, the Awenen Niin Act (Who Am I) Respecting Identity Documents, 2021, would amend the Photo Card Act, 2008, the Vital Statistics Act and the Strong Action for Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2012. Its stated goal is to address barriers to getting personal identification documents; that goal is not a guarantee that those barriers will end.
- It would prohibit fees for photo cards and for specified birth-related services and records, including birth certificates and certified copies of certain registrations.
- It would require the Minister of Government and Consumer Services to establish an advisory committee within 60 days after Royal Assent. The committee would make recommendations on systemic barriers to obtaining identification documents.
- The committee would have to consult specified groups, report within six months of being established, and the Minister would have to tell the Assembly within 90 days which recommendations the Minister will implement.
- It would also remove fee-payment conditions from several provisions of the Vital Statistics Act. The supplied text does not establish that every service covered by those provisions would be free.
- One amendment to the Strong Action for Ontario Act would repeal a provision, but the supplied materials do not show what that provision does.
What it means for you#
- Photo-card applicants and holders: No fee could be charged for a photo card or for anything done or provided under the Photo Card Act.
- People seeking birth records or services: No fee could be charged for registering a birth, adding to or changing a birth registration, searching for a birth registration, getting a birth certificate, or getting a certified copy of a birth, change-of-name, death or stillbirth registration.
- People seeking other vital records: The bill removes fee-payment conditions from several other provisions, but the materials do not show whether fees could still be charged for every service involved. A birth search would still require the applicant to satisfy the Registrar General about their reason for needing the search.
- People changing a birth registration: The Registrar General would still have to receive evidence that satisfies them about the person’s identity, and any prescribed documents in the person’s possession. Removing a fee would not remove those requirements.
- People facing barriers: The committee would have to include people who face or have faced barriers, among others. The Minister must make reasonable efforts for the committee to reflect Ontario’s diversity, including Indigenous people, people with disabilities and people of diverse sexual orientation, gender identity and gender expression.
- Everyone seeking identification: The bill does not create a general right to receive identification, a new front-line service, or a process for applications, decisions or appeals.
Money#
No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- The bill would remove fees in the areas it specifies, but gives no estimate of lost fee revenue.
- Regulations may set remuneration and expense payments for committee members. The bill gives no amounts or estimate of the committee’s operating costs.
- The supplied material does not give the cost of providing staff or other support for the committee.
What is unclear#
- The parent Acts and current fee rules were not supplied, so current fees and the full effect of the amendments cannot be verified against current law.
- The bill does not explain what the repealed provision in the Strong Action for Ontario Act currently does.
- The bill does not require the Minister to implement the committee’s recommendations; it requires the Minister to tell the Assembly which recommendations the Minister will implement.
- The bill does not set out how the committee will be chosen beyond the listed composition requirements, how it will operate, or how its recommendations will be followed up.
- The bill does not set a start date for the change-of-name certificate amendment; that part would start on a date set by proclamation.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that fees can be a financial barrier to getting essential identity documents. Removing specified fees could make those documents more accessible.
- The committee would be required to hear from people affected by barriers and consult Indigenous organizations, community legal clinics and community health centres.
- Its list of issues includes financial and administrative obstacles as well as racism, language access, digital access and negative experiences with government institutions. This could help identify barriers beyond fees.
Case against#
- One concern is that removing fees and making recommendations may not resolve barriers such as identity evidence requirements, access to digital resources or difficulty navigating government systems.
- The committee is advisory. The bill does not require the Minister to implement its recommendations.
- The bill gives no cost estimate and does not specify the committee’s resources, operating process or oversight.
- It is unclear which fees remain possible under the provisions where the bill removes fee-payment conditions but does not expressly prohibit fees.