Summary#
Bill 256, Awenen Niin Act (Who Am I) Respecting Identity Documents, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Photo Card Act, 2008, Vital Statistics Act and Strong Action for Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2012. Its stated goal is to remove systemic barriers to getting personal identification documents. The supplied material does not include the Acts’ current texts, so their existing rules and the full effect of every amendment cannot be verified here.
- Photo cards would have no fee for applicants or holders for anything done or provided under the Photo Card Act.
- The Vital Statistics Act would prohibit fees for registering a birth; adding to or changing a birth registration; searching for a birth registration; obtaining a birth certificate; and obtaining certified copies of registrations of birth, change of name, death or still-birth.
- The bill would require the Minister to establish an advisory committee within 60 days of Royal Assent. The committee must consult specified groups, make recommendations on barriers, and report to the Minister within six months of being established.
- Within 90 days of receiving the report, the Minister must tell the Assembly which recommendations the Minister will implement. The bill does not require the Minister to implement the committee’s recommendations.
- The bill would also repeal a provision of the 2012 budget Act. Its effect cannot be verified from the supplied material.
What it means for you#
- Photo-card applicants and holders: You would not pay fees for anything done or provided under the Photo Card Act.
- People seeking vital records: The listed birth-related services and certified copies would be fee-free. The bill also removes fee wording from some other application and search provisions, but the supplied material does not establish the full effect on fees for services outside the explicit no-fee list.
- People facing barriers to identification: The committee must include people who face or have faced barriers, service providers and advocates, and academic researchers. The Minister must make reasonable efforts to reflect Ontario’s diversity, including the groups named in the bill.
- Indigenous organizations, community legal clinics and community health centres: The committee must consult them. It must also hold public consultations open to people who have experienced barriers, including people acting on behalf of others.
- The public: The bill creates an advisory process, not a new front-line service or a guarantee that recommendations will be adopted.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill removes fees for specified services, but gives no estimate of the resulting lost fee revenue or how those services would be funded.
- The Minister must establish the committee and the committee must consult and report. The bill gives no staffing or operating-cost estimate.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set committee-member pay and expenses by regulation; the bill does not require a payment or set an amount.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “personal identification documents” or “systemic barriers.”
- It does not set out how the committee will choose members, conduct its work beyond the required consultations, or assess and rank recommendations.
- It does not require the Minister to adopt recommendations, explain why others are not adopted, or report on later results.
- The full effect of the fee-related edits outside the explicit no-fee list, and of the repeal in the 2012 budget Act, cannot be checked without the current parent Acts and related rules.
- The supplied material does not state when the bill would receive Royal Assent or when all its provisions would take effect. One change to the Vital Statistics Act would start on a day set by proclamation.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address barriers that are not just about fees, including language access, digital access, racism, difficult processes and negative experiences with government.
- Removing fees for the listed documents could reduce one direct cost of obtaining identification and vital records.
- Requiring consultations with affected people and named service organizations could bring practical experience into recommendations for change.
- A committee report followed by a ministerial response would make recommendations and the Minister’s chosen actions visible to the Assembly.
Case against#
- The committee can recommend changes, but the bill does not require the Minister to implement them. The main process could therefore produce recommendations without changing services.
- The bill does not define key terms or set detailed rules for how barriers will be assessed, making the committee’s scope and results uncertain.
- Fee removal may reduce revenue, while the bill provides no cost estimate or funding plan.
- The bill requires consultations and a report on fixed timelines but does not specify how the work will be staffed or how the Minister will account for recommendations not adopted.