Fee waivers for photo cards and birth certificates

Summary#

Bill 26, the Fee Waivers (Photo Card and Birth Certificate) Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Photo Card Act, 2008 and Vital Statistics Act. Its stated goal is to allow fee waivers for people who cannot afford photo cards or birth certificates. The bill would create a discretionary waiver power for photo-card fees and make birth-certificate fee waivers an express subject of regulations.

  • The minister responsible for the Photo Card Act may waive all or part of a photo-card fee for an applicant or cardholder who cannot afford it, subject to regulations.
  • Regulations under the Vital Statistics Act could provide fee waivers for any person or class of persons, including people who cannot afford a birth certificate.
  • The bill does not itself guarantee a waiver or set the detailed rules for who gets one.
  • If passed, it would come into force on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Photo-card applicants and holders: The minister would have power to waive all or part of the fee if you cannot afford it. Whether you qualify, and how to seek a waiver, would depend on regulations or other processes not set out in the bill.
  • People seeking birth certificates: Regulations could provide waivers for you or a class of people that includes you. The bill itself does not require a waiver in any individual case.
  • People generally: The bill does not change the fees for everyone, create a new benefit program, or set an application, decision, or appeal process.
  • Government: The responsible minister would have the photo-card waiver power. The birth-certificate change would allow regulations to provide waivers. The supplied material does not identify who would decide individual birth-certificate requests.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not appropriate money or state an administrative cost.
  • If waivers are used, the government could collect less in photo-card or birth-certificate fees. The amount is not stated.

What is unclear#

  • What “cannot afford” means, and what evidence a person would need to provide.
  • Whether regulations would set a standard process, timelines, reasons for decisions, or a way to challenge a refusal.
  • How often waivers would be granted, and whether they would cover all or only part of a fee.
  • The bill does not include the full current versions of the amended Acts. The supplied explanatory note says the changes add fee-waiver provisions, but the exact existing rules and how the amendments interact with them could not be verified.
  • The bill does not state when regulations would be made or provide a cost estimate.

Case for#

  • A fee may be a barrier for someone who needs a photo card or birth certificate. Waiver powers could address that barrier for people who cannot afford the fee.
  • Allowing all or part of a fee to be waived gives the minister flexibility to respond to a person’s circumstances, subject to regulations.
  • Letting regulations set birth-certificate waiver rules could allow waivers for individuals or defined groups.

Case against#

  • The bill says the minister may waive photo-card fees; it does not require a waiver for someone who cannot afford one.
  • The bill does not itself establish birth-certificate eligibility rules or guarantee that regulations will provide a waiver.
  • Without a definition of “cannot afford” or a process for applying and challenging decisions, access could depend on rules and practices not described in the bill.
  • The government could collect less fee revenue if waivers are granted, but the bill gives no estimate of that effect or of the cost of administering waivers.