Bill would cap agency staffing in healthcare

Summary#

Bill 144, Healthcare Staffing Agencies Act, 2023, would create a new Act. Its stated approach is to reduce and end hospitals’ and long-term care homes’ use of healthcare staffing agencies, while requiring plans to protect patient care during the transition. The bill would place duties on facilities and agencies; it would not create a new agency regulator.

  • Hospitals and long-term care homes in municipalities with at least 8,000 people would have to publish a plan within six months and update it every six months. The plan must include spending figures and measures to protect safe, quality and humane care.
  • The plans must set lower limits on agency spending over time. After 24 months, covered facilities must stop using staffing agencies. The limits differ by municipality size.
  • Agencies established after the Act starts would have to operate as not-for-profits. The bill does not impose that rule on agencies already established.
  • Agencies could not pay workers assigned to facilities more than 10% above the facility’s existing rate for the same profession. Travel, accommodation and per diem charges must be public, paid directly to the worker and kept within limits set by regulation.
  • Agencies could not poach facility employees. They also could not assign workers employed by a facility, or who left one in the previous 12 months, in the same or an adjacent Ontario Health Team.
  • Agencies receiving more than $400,000 in total from Ontario or its transfer payment agencies would be subject to oversight by four named offices. Their employees would be included on the Sunshine List.

What it means for you#

  • Hospitals and long-term care homes: If located in a municipality with at least 8,000 people, they would have to publish and regularly update a plan, reduce agency spending on a timetable, and end agency use after 24 months. The person in charge of nursing care must have a leadership role in developing the plan.
  • Patients and families: The plan must include measures to protect safe, quality and humane care during the transition. The bill does not specify what those measures must be.
  • Healthcare staffing agencies: New agencies would have to be not-for-profit. Agencies could not pay assigned workers more than the stated 10% premium, poach facility employees, or make the specified assignments. A breach of the poaching ban could bring a fine of up to $1 million.
  • Agency workers: The bill would require certain travel, accommodation and per diem charges to be made public and paid directly to the worker. It does not set the charge limits itself.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not set a new tax or fee. It directs collected fines to hospitals and long-term care homes.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Facilities would have to limit agency spending and eventually stop using agencies, but the bill gives no estimate of resulting costs or savings.
  • Facilities and agencies may need staff time to prepare plans, report spending and meet the bill’s rules; no amount is provided.
  • Fine revenue would go to hospitals and long-term care homes, but the bill does not estimate how much might be collected.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how “spending on staffing” is calculated, or when municipality population is measured.
  • It does not explain how “existing rate” for a profession is set, or who determines whether an agency has poached an employee.
  • The bill leaves the permitted limits on travel, accommodation and per diem charges to future regulations.
  • It does not set out how the four oversight offices would coordinate, or what period counts toward the $400,000 threshold.
  • It does not explain how facilities would maintain staffing after agency use ends, or how the required care-protection measures would be assessed.
  • No publicly available information on the bill’s current status or whether it has become law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would reduce facilities’ reliance on staffing agencies through clear, staged spending limits and a final end date.
  • Requiring plans to be public and updated every six months could make facilities’ agency spending and transition measures visible.
  • The required role for the person in charge of nursing care, and the duty to plan for safe and humane care, connect the transition to patient-care concerns.
  • Limits on agency pay premiums and extra charges could make agency staffing costs more transparent and constrained.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a fixed end to agency use could leave facilities without enough staff if they cannot replace agency workers in time. The bill requires care-protection measures but does not set a staffing fallback.
  • The bill does not explain how its spending limits would work in practice, or how compliance would be checked.
  • The rules may affect agencies differently: only agencies established after the Act starts must be not-for-profit, while the spending limits apply to facilities’ use of agencies generally.
  • The assignment ban could reach workers who left a facility within the previous 12 months and work in the same or an adjacent Ontario Health Team, but the bill does not define how that boundary is determined.