Plan to Create Independent Consumer Watchdog

Summary#

Bill 122, the Ontario Consumer Watchdog Act, 2023, would create a new law. It would require the Minister of Public and Business Service Delivery (or another assigned minister) to develop and implement a plan to establish an independent consumer watchdog. The stated goal is to improve consumer protection in Ontario; the bill does not itself establish the watchdog or give it operating powers.

  • The Minister must consult relevant stakeholders and the public when developing the plan, then publish the plan on a Government of Ontario website.
  • The plan must set out the steps to establish the watchdog and its proposed powers and duties. These must include investigating businesses and consumer complaints; reporting on unfair practices; administering penalties or determining consumer remedies; publishing complaint and investigation information; reviewing whether legislation is outdated or poorly enforced; reporting to the Legislature, committees and ministries; and educating the public.
  • The plan must address the watchdog’s relationship with other regulators, including a way for its decisions to prevail over other regulators’ decisions in specified sectors or for specified groups.
  • Within six months after the plan is developed, the Minister must prepare and table a progress report in the Legislative Assembly.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: The bill does not directly create a new complaints service, remedy or protection. Those are matters the plan must address as possible duties and powers of the watchdog.
  • Businesses and other entities: The bill does not itself impose new compliance rules or penalties. The plan must set out possible watchdog powers involving investigations, penalties and consumer remedies.
  • Minister and government: The Minister must develop and implement the plan, consult the public and relevant stakeholders, publish the plan and table a progress report. The bill does not set a deadline for developing the plan.
  • Other regulators: The plan must explain the watchdog’s role in relation to them, including how its decisions could take priority in specified areas. The bill does not itself transfer existing powers or make watchdog decisions override other regulators.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The bill requires the Minister to develop and implement a plan, but gives no cost estimate or staffing figure.
  • It does not appropriate a specific amount of money or set fees or fines. The plan’s proposed powers include penalties, but the bill does not itself establish them.

What is unclear#

  • When the plan must be completed, and when the watchdog would start operating.
  • What “independent of government” would mean in practice, including how the watchdog would be appointed, funded and overseen.
  • How investigations and complaints would work, including who could complain, decision timelines, review or appeal rights, and how remedies or penalties would be set.
  • Which sectors or groups could be covered by decisions that prevail over other regulators, and how conflicts between regulators would be resolved.
  • Which existing powers under other laws, including the Consumer Protection Act, 2002, would be assigned to the watchdog.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address concerns named in its preamble, including unfair business practices, poor marketplace transparency and consumer protections that are hard to access or rely on.
  • A watchdog with investigation, complaint, reporting and public education roles could bring several consumer-protection functions together.
  • Requiring publication of complaint and investigation information could make the watchdog’s work visible to consumers and businesses.
  • Requiring the plan to address the watchdog’s relationship with other regulators could help identify where responsibilities overlap.

Case against#

  • The bill requires a plan, not an operating watchdog. It does not set a launch date or guarantee that consumers will receive a new service or remedy.
  • The plan must address substantial powers, including penalties and decisions that could prevail over other regulators, but the bill leaves their limits and safeguards to the plan.
  • The bill does not set a deadline for developing the plan or specify how the watchdog would be funded, appointed or held accountable.
  • The watchdog’s role could overlap with existing regulators. The bill requires the plan to address that relationship but does not set rules for resolving conflicts.